If you sign up for Humble Monthly before the changeover, you'll get instant access to this month's early unlock games: Yakuza Kiwami, Soulcalibur VI, and My Time at Portia. Then, on December 6, an additional bundle of mystery games will unlock. As it does, Humble Monthly will become Humble Choice, and you'll automatically be put on the Classic plan.
Anyone joining the service after it changes to Humble Choice will have three plans to choose from. The Lite plan costs $4.99 per month and gets you access to the Humble Trove (a collection of around 90 games), a 10% Humble Store discount, and limited access to Humble-published originals and betas. The Basic plan costs $14.99 and covers everything in Lite plan, plus you can pick three games from a list of 10 each month to keep forever. The Premium plan offers the same features, but you can pick nine games each month, and you get a 20% Humble Store discount.
The Classic plan, meanwhile, gets you everything in the Premium plan, but you get all 10 games each month, and it only costs $12 per month. This is by far the best deal.
The only catch is that you have to maintain your subscription to stay on the Classic plan. (You can suspend your subscription without losing access, but if you cancel it, it's gone.) You can read the Classic plan FAQ and the Humble Choice FAQ for more information.
Long story short, if you're interested in receiving a curated selection of PC games each month, joining Humble Monthly before 10 AM PT December 6 will far and away get you the best deal.
Disclosure: Humble Bundle is owned by Ziff Davis, the parent company of IGN. Humble Bundle and IGN operate completely independently, and no special consideration is given to Humble Bundle announcements or promotions for coverage.
If you buy something through this post, IGN may get a share of the sale. For more, learn more.