It appears as though your computer is not cookie-enabled. In order to log into nymag.com, your browser needs to be set to accept cookies from nymag.com. A cookie is small piece of information stored by your browser which allows you to remain logged in as you move from page to page.
Please change your browser settings to accept cookies in either the "Tools" or "Preferences" menu, depending on what kind of browser you use.
To learn more about cookies:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HTTP_cookie