Menu
Popular dishes
People also searched for
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Barbeque, Steakhouses, American
in Delis, Sandwiches, Fast Food
Amenities and More
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Rotolo's Pizzeria.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
55 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- Jul 21, 2022
My daughter and I ate here for lunch. We ordered the parmesan garlic bites and the 12 inch half cheese and half pepperoni pizza. Our server was very nice, efficient, and attentive. The food came out in good time. AND WOW! Those parmesan garlic bites were flavorful and soft. The pizza is hands down the best pizza, in my opinion, in the area. I will be bringing back our family for dinner here for sure.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Oct 9, 2022Updated review
We came back again, and this time with friends. We had more of a variety of food. It was all very good again. The Children's Mac and Cheese is definitely portioned for older kids, my toddler could have eaten off this for 3 days. My friends enjoyed the calzones. Our server was very attentive and patient with us as we had 2 preschoolers with us. We really enjoyed ourselves.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0Jul 21, 2022Previous reviewMy daughter and I ate here for lunch. We ordered the parmesan garlic bites and the 12 inch half cheese and half pepperoni pizza. Our server was very nice, efficient, and attentive. The food came out in good time. AND WOW! Those parmesan garlic bites were flavorful and soft. The pizza is hands down the best pizza, in my opinion, in the area. I will be bringing back our family for dinner here for sure.
- 423714417May 29, 2022
Some solid pizza in Fairhope! AND they have an arcade in the back :0)
I only minus one star due to realizing I would not order the adult size pizza again (felt it was under cooked) I was jealous of the kids pizza (pure perfection) and when I'm in town again, if we venture here, I'll be ordering the childrens size for myself too!!! Lol
Staff is super friendly, welcoming and happy. Place is clean enough, I'm sure they are struggling with being understaffed as is everyone.
Overall, great service, good food, killer arcadeHelpful 1Thanks 0Love this 4Oh no 0 - Tina S.Daphne, AL10157272Nov 15, 2022Updated review
This was my first time at this place. We picked the pizzas up because delivery would have been 2 hour wait. It was nice and hot but I am picky about my everything so I wasn't pleased with this pizza. I don't like a lot of red sauce, it's so thick, I believe a little goes a long way. Not only was it too saucy but the sauce was so dark in color which to me meant very tomato pasty. If you like thick red sauce then this is your place. It was a bit high cost wise as well as everything is these days. I think if the sauce had been a bit lighter the pizza would have been good. The crust was very good. I prefer thin crust but I let my husband have the thicker crust this time.
Helpful 3Thanks 0Love this 3Oh no 1Oct 15, 2021Previous reviewThe place was practically empty when we got there. We went there about a month ago and the only thing I remember was the garlic bites because they were delicious! I ordered a sandwich but I didn't see it had this sweet sauce on it so I sent it back and the second sandwich was delicious but they didn't have mayonnaise so I took it home to eat. The server was good but upon coming into restaurant he was chewing gum but luckily he spat it out. I've been in this industry long enough to know we DON'T chew gum, it's rude and against health board policies. I think I'll go back because of the garlic bites!
- Jimmy S.Panama City Beach, FL01314Oct 29, 2022
Stop reading the 1 star reviews. Anyone that walks out before ordering doesn't count. Anyone who says they are intimidated by kitchen staff is, well, going to be intimidated by butter at some point.
Food:
ParmGar knots are fire!
Wings smelled great but at the time we got there they were out. Nbd
Pizza was great. Loved Maui Wowi (no onions)
Arcade was great. Babysitter for sure. Worth it.
Waitress. Didn't recall her name, but awesome. She worked the back and won!
Suggestions, drink menus and maybe more wings. Lol.
Thanks for the trip there!Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Alletta J.AL, AL02Mar 31, 2023
Best salad as in the spinach, walnut cranberry, and the pizza was delicious and I don't know why I've been going anywhere else. I recommend Rotolo's
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0Business owner information
Emelie B.
Apr 24, 2023
Thank you for the kind words, Alletta! We appreciate your business!
- Mary Katherine L.Overton, Birmingham, AL1774077Mar 20, 2022
Mad we waited this long to try this local pizza stop. We ordered to-go through the website which was super simple, and it was ready when we arrived The staff was nice and checked our order before passing it over the bar. We can't wait to go back and dine in and try out the arcade with the little one.. and get some more Parmesan bites!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Susan W.Foley, AL06Nov 1, 2022
I really love the calzones here and their Caesar salad. I would definitely give your waitress a heads up when you think you might need something because like with a lot of places nowadays, they are usually shorthanded.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Molly A.Fairhope, AL5116104Dec 3, 2021
This place has GOT to quit doing that thing where every single worker ignores the customer and/or walks away from them. Maybe I'm a masochist, but I keep coming back despite the sometimes bad service. The food is good, almost always fresh. The pizzas are unique. But at least once a year, I get straight ignored when I walk in. Today was one of those days. I was really hoping they were over that bad habit. They clearly are not.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Oct 27, 2018Updated review
This our go to restaurant for pizza. The pizza crusis thick and yummy. The marinara sauce has just the right spice, mild and they don't load up the pizza with too much sauce. The ingredients are fresh. The waitresses are very nice and they make the experience very happy and pleasant. The wings are mildly spiced but you can order them as Spivey as you would like. They are large wing, I couldn't finish the 10 piece dinner. The blue cheese dressing is unremarkable, but tasted fine.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0Oct 15, 2017Previous reviewThe pizza was partially baked on one side and fully baked on the other. The ingredients were good and I could barely see the sauce. What sauce I did have was tasty and with a little spice. The pie was filling. We had the cinnamon puffs were good with chocolate and Carmel drizzled was good but I would have liked to dip in the side. Not enough of a good thing. The staff was friendly and prompt. The price is average for a pizza joint.
You Might Also Consider
in Pizza
in Italian