Acta Palaeobotanica 47(2): 419–424, 2007
Trapa kvacekii (Trapaceae), a remarkable
new fossil species from the late Miocene
of Greece
JAN J. WÓJCICKI 1 and DIMITRIOS VELITZELOS 2
1
W. Szafer Institute of Botany, Polish Academy of Sciences, Lubicz 46, 31-512 Kraków, Poland;
e-mail: jan.wojcicki@ib-pan.krakow.pl
2
National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Faculty of Geology and Geoenvironment,
Panepistimioupolis Zografou, Athens, Greece; e-mail: veljim@otenet.gr
Received 16 August 2006; accepted for publication 16 July 2007
ABSTRACT. Trapa kvacekii Wójcicki & D. Velitzelos (Trapaceae), a new fossil species from the late Miocene
of Likudi near Elassone (Thessalia, Greece) is described, illustrated and briefly discussed. It differs markedly
from its congeners by fruit morphology, primarily by the characteristic fruit body oblong-triangular in outline,
well-developed high ring at the base, and stout lower horns inserted 3/5 to 3/4 the distance from the base of
the fruit.
KEY WORDS: Trapa, Trapaceae, new species, fruit morphology, late Miocene, Greece
INTRODUCTION
The late Miocene diatomites in Likudi near
Elassona (Thessalia, Greece) are known from
rich and well-preserved leaf flora (Velitzelos
& Gregor 1985, 1986, 1990, Knobloch & Velitzelos 1986, 1987, Mai 1995, Velitzelos et al.
2000). Their unique character is manifested
by four new species of trees – Quercus dubia
Knobloch & Velitzelos, Q. likudensis Knobloch
& Velitzelos, Ostrya likudensis Knobloch
& Velitzelos, and Salix massalongii Knobloch
& Velitzelos, restricted to this locality (Knobloch & Velitzelos 1987) – and one legume
Gymnocladocarpum velitzelosii Gregor of the
subfamily Caesalpinioideae, probably ancestral to SE North American Gymnocladus dioicus (L.) K. Koch (Gregor 1986).
Recent collections of the second author
yielded new material from Likudi (Fig. 1),
including several relatively well-preserved
impressions of Trapa fruits of interesting morphology, which represent a new fossil species
described here.
Fig. 1. Geographic location of the site of Trapa kvacekii
Wójcicki & D. Velitzelos sp. nov. at Likudi near Elassona,
Greece
420
MATERIAL AND METHODS
Nine Trapa specimens exist as impressions in soft
whitish or yellowish finely bedded diatomite, sometimes with remnants of oxidised and/or carbonised
endocarp. They were collected from an erosion-exposed
slope in a valley between Likudi and Kleisura, ca.
10 km NW of Elassona (Fig. 1) marked on a schematic
map provided by Velitzelos and Gregor (1986, Fig. 3)
as “Likudi 5”. Trapa fossils are reported from this
place as Trapa sp. by Velitzelos and Gregor (1990),
but they have not been described so far. The age of the
locality is not precise, but according to Knobloch and
Velitzelos (1987) it is late Miocene, younger than late
Badenian (see also Kovar-Eder et al. 2006).
Most fruit impressions from Likudi are relatively
well preserved (Figs 2, 3) and they bear characteristics that permit more precise interpretation of their
morphology. Six of them are impressions of almost
complete fruit compressions in the plane of the upper
horns (Figs 2A–C, 3A–E, G). Two other fruits were
positioned differently in the sediment, one in the plane
of the lower horns (Fig. 3F) and the other obliquely in
the plane of the upper horns (Figs 2D, 3H), enabling
confirmation of the presence of well-developed lower
horns, and their characterisation.
To stabilise the morphology of the Trapa fruit
impressions and to prevent degradation and removal
of organic matter, the samples were coated with arti-
ficial resin (Poraloid dissolved in acetone) after preparation of the specimens. Photographic documentation
was made with a standard Nikon Coolpix 995 digital
camera. The contrast was enhanced by low-angle
light.
The material described here is housed in the
palaeobotanical collection of the Department of Historical Geology and Palaeontology, Athens University,
Athens (DHGPA; eight specimens), and one specimen,
kindly donated by the second author, is stored in
the Palaeobotanical Museum of the W. Szafer Institute of Botany, Polish Academy of Sciences, Kraków
(KRAM-P). Comparative fossil plant material was
studied by the first author in the palaeobotanical collections of Barcelona (Departament d’Estratigrafia,
Paleontologia i Geociències Marines, Universitat
de Barcelona), Beijing (Institute of Botany, Chinese Academy of Sciences), Berlin (Museum für
Naturkunde), Brno (The Moravian Museum), Bucharest (Department of Geology and Palaeontology, University of Bucharest), Budapest (Hungarian Natural
History Museum and Geological Institute of Hungary),
Cottbus (Museum der Natur und Umwelt), Dresden
(Staatliche Sammlungen, Museum für Mineralogie
und Geologie), Frankfurt (Palaeobotanical Section
of the Forschungsinstitut Senckenberg), Kraków
(W. Szafer Institute of Botany, Polish Academy of
Sciences), London (Palaeontological Collection of the
British Museum – Natural History), Munich (Bayer-
Fig. 2. Trapa kvacekii Wójcicki & D. Velitzelos sp. nov. from Likudi near Elassona. A – No. DHGPA L/Tr/1 (= Fig. 3A),
B – DHGPA L/Tr/5 (= Fig. 3D), C – DHGPA L/Tr/2 (= Fig. 3B), D – DHGPA L/Tr/9 (= Fig. 3H); A – holotype, B, C – paratype.
a – apical aperture, bh – base of lower horn, h – head, lh – lower horn, n – neck, r – ring, ri – ribs, s – scar, t – trace of
tubercle, uh – upper horn; scale bar 1 cm
421
ische Staatssammlung für Paläontologie und Geologie
in Munich), Nanjing (Institute of Geology and Palaeontology, Chinese Academy of Sciences), Stockholm
(Swedish Museum of Natural History), St. Petersburg
(Komarov Botanical Institute, Russian Academy of
Sciences), Turin (Museo di Geologia e Paleontologia of
the Turin University) and Vienna (Geological-Palaeontological Department of the Natural History Museum).
Extant plant material was studied in or obtained on
loan from the following herbaria: B, BM, BP, CAL, FI,
KRAM, KW, LE, LY, MW, MHA, P, PE, PR, PRC, S,
W, WU, Z (acronyms follow Holmgren et al. 1990).
Fig. 3. Trapa kvacekii Wójcicki & D. Velitzelos sp. nov. from Likudi near Elassona. A – No. DHGPA L/Tr/1 (= Fig. 2A),
B – DHGPA L/Tr/2 (= Fig. 2B), C – KRAM-P 249, D – DHGPA L/Tr/5 (= Fig. 2B), E – DHGPA L/Tr/6, F – DHGPA L/Tr/7,
G – DHGPA L/Tr/8, H – DHGPA L/Tr/9 (= Fig. 2D), I – neck of H with visible upward-pointing hairs closing apical aperture;
A – holotype, B, C, D – paratypes. a – apical aperture, bh – base of lower horn, f – frame, h – head, lh – lower horn, n – neck,
r – ring, ri – ribs, s – scar, t – trace of tubercle, uh – upper horn; scale bars 1 cm
422
SYSTEMATICS
Trapaceae Doum. nom. cons.
Trapa kvacekii Wójcicki
& D. Velitzelos sp. nov.
Figs 2A–D, 3A–I
H o l o t y p e (designated here). Coll. file No.
DHGPA L/Tr/1 (Figs 2A & 3A).
P a r a t y p e s. Coll. file Nos DHGPA L/Tr/2
(Figs 2C & 3B), L/Tr /5 (Figs 2B & 3D); KRAMP 249 (Fig. 3C).
F u r t h e r m a t e r i a l. Coll. file Nos DHGPA
L/Tr/3, L/Tr/6 (Fig. 3E), L/Tr/7 (Fig. 3F), L/Tr/8
(Fig. 3G), L/Tr/9 (Figs 2D & 3H).
T y p e l o c a l i t y. Erosion exposed slope in
a valley between Likudi and Kleisura near
Elassona, Thessalia, Greece (ALikudi 5@ according to Velitzelos & Gregor 1986).
T y p e h o r i z o n. Yellowish diatomite.
A g e. Late Miocene.
D e r i v a t i o n o f t h e n a m e. Named after
the eminent Czech palaeobotanist Professor
Zlatko Kvaček in recognition of his contribution to Tertiary palaeobotany.
D i a g n o s i s a n d d e s c r i p t i o n. Large
fruits, oblong-triangular in outline, with two
pairs of solid horns; fruit 31–41 mm high
(including neck), width of fruit at upper horns
40–55 mm; fruit about 1.3 times as wide as
high; fruit head pronounced, 8–10 mm long,
its upper end situated below the line joining
the bases of the upper horns, bearing a welldeveloped neck usually somewhat narrowing
towards the apex; neck 3–4 mm long and
3.5–5.0 mm broad, slightly protruding beyond
the line joining the bases of the upper horns,
corona lacking; apical aperture with a ring of
upward-pointing hairs; surface of fruit head
and neck finely ribbed; upper horns triangular
in outline, (14) 16–22 mm long, at least slightly
raised at the base, gradually attenuating into
straight, elongate, thin, spine-like tips, ascending (50°–65°), with a smooth surface except
for poorly marked, at least 6 mm long, retrorsely barbed spines (harpoons); presence of mat
areas excluded; lower horns narrowly triangular in outline, up to 14 mm long, and about 8
mm wide at the base, at least slightly retrorse,
straight or with gently upward-pointing apical
part, inserted usually 3/5 to 3/4 the distance
from the base of the fruit; the frame of the fruit
well developed; on the fruit frame between the
bases of the upper and lower horns, solid, probably conical (truncate?) tubercles developed,
traces of their bases up to 4 mm in diameter;
lower part of the fruit body obtriangular in
outline, truncate at the base, its surface (on
one side only) covered with five protruding longitudinal ribs; fruit base with a smooth ring,
up to 3 mm high; basal scar probably up to 3
mm in diameter.
DISCUSSION
Trapa kvacekii is a new well-defined fossil species of the late Miocene of Europe
with a unique combination of characters
never reported previously (see Wójcicki 2002,
Wójcicki & Zastawniak 2003 and Kovar-Eder
et al. 2005 for references). It is characterized
by having fruits with the fruit body oblong-triangular in outline, solid, relatively long lower
horns inserted 3/5 to 3/4 the distance from its
base and a well developed high ring at the
base (Figs 2, 3). In addition, Trapa kvacekii
possesses the largest fruit body of all Tertiary
fossil Trapa described so far. The fruits from
Likudi seem not to vary much, and the variation observed is probably due to fossilisation
and the position of the fruit in the sediment
(Fig. 3).
From the Balkan Peninsula there are several late Neogene localities with fossil Trapa
remains reported. One is the Kreka Basin near
Tuzla in Bosnia of the late Miocene. On the
basis of single specimens, Janković and Pantić
(1953; see also Janković 1958) described four
separate fossil species from this locality:
Trapa bosniaca Janković & Pantić, T. tuzlensis Janković & Pantić, T. pontica Janković
& Pantić, and T. praemuzzanensis Janković
& Pantić. From the protologues and figures
it is evident that T. bosniaca and T. tuzlensis differ in fruit shape and size from the
species newly described from Likudi. Unlike
T. kvacekii, their fruits are broadly rounded
at the base, with a pair of relatively short
upward-pointing upper horns and reduced
lower horns inserted probably 1/3 the distance
from the base of the fruit. It is possible that
T. bosniaca and T. tuzlensis represent the
same fossil species. The original descriptions of
423
the other two species, T. pontica and T. praemuzzanensis, are based on poorly preserved,
incomplete specimens showing some similarity to T. silesiaca Goeppert emend. Wójcicki
& Zastawniak, widely distributed in Europe
in the late Miocene (Wójcicki & Zastawniak
2002, Kovar-Eder et al. 2005). The identity
of the fruits from Kreka remains unsolved,
requiring detailed reinvestigation of the original material.
Other localities with Trapa remains from
the Balkan region are of Pliocene age, reported
from south-western Romania (Dacic Basin) by
Givulescu and Ţicleanu (1986) and Ţicleanu
(1995, 2003). The characteristic morphology of
Trapa fruits from these localities (e.g., stalked
and/or abruptly elongated fruit base) suggests
that they are evidently of separate evolutionary
lineage (Wójcicki & Ţicleanu, in preparation).
The fruits of T. kvacekii show some similarity to those from the Pliocene of Arboschio (Villafranca d’Asti, Italy), originally classified by
Pavia (1970: tab. 4, fig. 1) as T. natans L., but
they differ in some aspects. Like T. kvacekii,
the specimens from Arboschio are obtriangular
and somewhat elongate in outline, with solid
lower horns, relatively big tubercles on the
fruit frame between the bases of the upper
and lower horns, and a well-developed smooth
basal ring up to 2 mm high. The difference of
the specimens from Italy is best marked by
their smaller size (about 25 mm high and 32
mm wide at upper horns), the position of the
lower horns (inserted approximately in the
centre of the fruit body), and the presence of
a corona on the neck, a character unknown in
representatives of the Trapa genus described
from the Miocene.
There are at least a few unnamed modern
morphotypes scattered in the southern part of
Europe, placed in the still poorly recognized
T. natans complex, with a visibly elongated
fruit body obtriangular in outline, relatively
stout lower horns located above the centre of
the fruit, bearing at least small tubercles on
the fruit frame between the lower and upper
horns, and a smooth basal ring (Wójcicki,
personal observation). Despite the obvious
morphological differences, such a combination of characters suggests their similarity to
T. kvacekii, and leads us to suspect that the
newly described species may have given rise
to some extant morphotypes, but convergence
cannot be ruled out.
Similarly to some other fossil Trapa species of the Miocene of Europe (Kovar-Eder et
al. 2005), T. kvacekii was probably endemic to
the late Miocene of Thessalia; it highlights the
unique character of its flora.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Special thanks are due to J. Kovar-Eder (Stuttgart), E. Zastawniak (Kraków) and Z. Kvaček (Prague)
for valuable scientific discussions and to the two
anonymous reviewers for helpful comments on the
manuscript. The first author is additionally grateful
to the curators and keepers of the palaeobotanical collections of Barcelona (C. Martin-Closas), Berlin (D.H.
Mai), Beijing (C.S. Li), Brno (R. Gregorova), Bucharest
(N. Ţicleanu), Budapest (L. Hably, L. Kordos), Cottbus
(U. & R. Striegler), Dresden (L. Kunzmann), Frankfurt
(V. Wilde), Kraków (E. Zastawniak), London (P. Kenrick), Munich (W. Jung, H. Mayr), Nanjing (S.X. Guo),
Stockholm (M.E. Friis), St. Petersburg (S.G. Zhilin),
Turin (E. Martinetto) and Vienna (J. Eder), as well
as to the curators of the herbaria B, BM, BP, CAL,
FI, KRAM, KW, LE, LY, MW, MHA, P, PE, PR, PRC,
S, W, WU, Z for kindly allowing him to study comparative fossil and extant material, to J.W. Wieser
(Kraków) for drawings of Trapa specimens, and to
M. Jacobs (Miechów) for verification of the English
text. This work was supported in part by the Polish
State Committee for Scientific Research (KBN grant
6 P04D 034 15).
REFERENCES
GIVULESCU R. & ŢICLEANU N. 1986. Fossile
Trapa-Früchte aus Rumänien. Dări de Seam ale
Şedinţelor, 3. Paleontologie [1983, 1984], 70–71(3):
187–193.
GREGOR H.-J. 1986. Gymnocladocarpum velitzelosii
nov. gen. et spec. aus den obermiozänen Diatomiten von Likudi (Griechenland). Documenta Naturae, 29: 41–43.
HOLMGREN P.K., HOLMGREN N.H. & BARNETT
L.C. 1990. Index herbariorum. Part 1. The herbaria
of the World. Regnum Veg., 120: 1–693.
JANKOVIĆ M. 1958. Oekologie, Verbreitung, Systematik und Geschichte der Gattung Trapa L. in
Jugoslawien. Societe Serbe de Biologie, Editions
Speziales, 2: 1–143.
JANKOVIĆ M. & PANTIĆ N. 1953. Fossilarten der
Gattung Trapa L. in Nord-Ost-Bosnien. Ann. Geol.
Penins. Balkan., 21: 133–142.
KNOBLOCH E. & VELITZELOS E. 1986. Die obermiozäne Flora von Likudi bei Elassona/Thessalien,
Griechenland. Documenta Naturae, 29: 5–20.
KNOBLOCH E. & VELITZELOS E. 1987. New leaf
floras in the Neogene of Greece. Věst. Ústř. Úst.
Geol., 62(3): 157–164.
KOVAR-EDER J., WÓJCICKI J.J. & ZETTER R.
2005. Trapaceae from the late Miocene of Austria
424
and the European context. Acta Palaeobot., 45(2):
165–186.
KOVAR-EDER J., KVAČEK Z., MARTINETTO E.
& ROIRON P. 2006. Late Miocene to Early Pliocene
vegetation of southern Europe (7–4Ma) as reflected
in the megafossil plant record. Palaeogeogr. Palaeoclimatol. Palaeoecol., 238(1–4): 321–339.
MAI D.H. 1995. Tertiäre Vegetationsgeschichte Europas. Gustav Fischer Verlag, Jena, Stuttgart, New
York.
PAVIA G. 1970. Rest di anancus arvernensis e flora
ad affinità plioceniche nel Villafranchiano inferiore
dellla Cava Arboschio (Villafranca d’Asti). Mem.
Soc. Geol. Ital., 9: 157–176.
ŢICLEANU N. 1995. Macroflore et végétation daciennes du Basin Dacique: 473–528. In: Marinescu F.
& Papaianopol I. (eds) Chronostratigraphie und
Neostratotypen. Neogen der Zentrale Paratethys.
Bd. 9. Dacien. Akademie, Bucureşti.
ŢICLEANU N. 2003. La flore du Romanien: 442–
467. In: Papaianapol I., Marinescu F., Krstić N.
& Macaleţ R. (eds) Chronostratigraphie und Neostratotypen. Neogen der Zentrale Paratethys.
Pliozän Pl2, Bd. 10. Romanien. Editura Akademiei
Române, Bucureşti.
VELITZELOS E. & GREGOR H.-J. 1985. Neue paläofloristische Befunde im Neogen Griechenlands.
Documenta Naturae, 25: 1–4.
VELITZELOS E. & GREGOR H.-J. 1986. Geologische Daten zu den fossilführenden Fundstellen
Lava, Prossilion und Likudi (Griechenland) nebst
Bemerkungen zu deren Frucht- und Samenflora.
Documenta Naturae, 29: 34–40.
VELITZELOS E. & GREGOR H.-J. 1990. Some
aspects of the Neogene floral history in Greece.
Rev. Palaeobot. Palynol., 62: 291–307.
VELITZELOS D., KVAČEK Z. & VELITZELOS E.
2000. Palaeoecological and climatological significance of conifer synusiae occurring in the Tertiary
of Greece. In: The Sixth Conference of International Organization of Palaeobotany (IOPC-VI),
Quinhuangdao. Abstract: 137–138.
WÓJCICKI J. J. 2002. Trapa assamica (Trapaceae),
a remarkable new extant species from the Indian
subcontinent. Polish Bot. J., 47(1): 5–9.
WÓJCICKI J.J. & ZASTAWNIAK E. 2002. Late
Miocene Trapa L. (Trapaceae) of Sośnica (SW
Poland) revisited. Acta Palaeobot., 42(1): 29–38.
WÓJCICKI J.J. & ZASTAWNIAK E. 2003. Rodzina
Trapaceae w trzeciorzędzie Europy – wstępne
wyniki badań (summary: The Trapaceae family
in the Tertiary of Europe – preliminary results).
Botanical Guidebooks, 26: 153–185.