Forum - View topicREVIEW: The Asterisk War Novel 1
Goto page 1, 2 Next Note: this is the discussion thread for this article |
View previous topic :: View next topic | |||
Author | Message | ||
---|---|---|---|
Izanagi009
Posts: 224 Location: Pittsburgh, PA, USA |
|
||
While I suppose that the Asterisk War LNs are better than their adaptations, I personally believe that it's still subpar compared to the annals of light novels. The romance angle feels stiffer compared to Holo and Lawrance from Spice and Wolf with the interactions seeming far too adversarial for it to be normal. In addition, Ayato in the LNs even later on in the story is far too bland for him with him seeming very stereotypical of a self-insert: generically kind and heroic, with a standard loyalty to the female lead and the others around him. Nothing about him stands out in any way.
I will also comment briefly on fights later on in the series as being too word heavy even for a literary genre though I suppose that's more personal. In fact, feel free to call me "pretentious" if desired as I understand how my language seems to others. |
|||
Back to top | |||
Princess_Irene
Posts: 1253 Location: The castle beyond the Goblin City |
|
||
I don't think your language sounds pretentious.
I can see how this series could go downhill as it goes on - the premise is definitely a bit thinner than comparable plots. Wordiness is a serious problem with LNs in general, and I suspect editorial oversight might be behind it to a degree, since it isn't an issue I've had reading translations of non-LN Japanese novels. They may have the opposite editorial stance about Young Adult fiction than the English-language markets, which is an interesting thought. In any event, I'll enjoy this while I can. Hopefully it takes a while before it stumbles. |
|||
Back to top | |||
SilverTalon01
Posts: 1218 |
|
||
I feel like the series has enough going on in the plot to make it interesting, but I also feel like the focus on the school tournaments holds the larger plot back a lot.
|
|||
Back to top | |||
Alan45
Village Elder
Posts: 6457 Location: Virginia |
|
||
Something I found to be a bit more explicit in the novel than in the anime is that these are modern day gladiators. The novel mentions in the tour of the city that the main stage is based in part on the Roman Coliseum. It is also noted in the information at the end that the fights of the Festa are broadcast worldwide and that they use students because they are young and beautiful. While they are not specifically supposed to kill each other they are basically risking serious injury or death strictly for entertainment purposes.
Since these are young people with powers it makes a sort of sense to control them by concentrating them in a single location and have them fight each other. It also explains why no one is really concerned if these students maim or kill each other. As explained in the information in the back they are called to this location by a combination of financial and other rewards combined with anti-genestella prejudice in the general population. In many of the other magic school series they are supposed to be training to protect the world or what is left of it from supernatural forces or outer space invaders. In those cases it always bothered me that they would let promising students destroy each other because of typical high school conflicts when they were needed so badly (Freezing being an example). |
|||
Back to top | |||
SkerllyF
Posts: 21 |
|
||
Can we have a review on Rakudai Kishi(LN),or can someone make a comparison with AW?
|
|||
Back to top | |||
G S Palmer
Posts: 50 |
|
||
Just as a heads up, that's the cover of the first manga volume, not the first light novel.
|
|||
Back to top | |||
Alan45
Village Elder
Posts: 6457 Location: Virginia |
|
||
I hope we can avoid this. I always thought it was unfortunate that both shows came out the same season. Too much time was spent comparing the two, to the point that it obscured the strengths and weakness of both shows. In the event that the Rakudai Kishi novel is published in English, I would hope that any review would be limited to that by itself. What matters is if a given volume is entertaining, if it is it doesn't matter is it is better or worse than a different title. Even if you establish a given title as "best in its genre" are you going to read that repeatedly in lieu of anything else in that genre? |
|||
Back to top | |||
Princess_Irene
Posts: 1253 Location: The castle beyond the Goblin City |
|
||
When/if the LN is licensed and released in English, I'd be happy to review it. But we have to get to that point first. I will say that when I hit the restaurant scene in this novel, I forgot for a second which series I was reading and had to remind myself that this was Asterisk and not Rakudai. EDIT: Alan45, I'm sure that whoever reviews it in the event of its release would stick to the book itself. I agree that's how it ought to be done. |
|||
Back to top | |||
SilverTalon01
Posts: 1218 |
|
||
They're pretty different even if they start out fairly similarly and share the magic battle high school tournament aspect. Asterisk is straight up harem rather just a single couple and does a lot more world building. By that I mean it explores the history of their world and introduces lots of different factions with different motivations. Rakudai is really driven by the development of the 2 leads and the development of their relationship. There is a plot lurking behind the tournament (basically a staple for the whole high school battle tournament shtick), but it really doesn't have the world building and set up behind it that Asterisk does. The plus side to a more shallow overall plot is that because the focus is really just on developing Ikki and Stella, it isn't really hamstrung by the school tournaments. On the other hand, the tournaments in Asterisk really feel like they're just in the way. |
|||
Back to top | |||
FilthyCasual
Posts: 555 |
|
||
Did Ayato's sister tongue him too :lol: |
|||
Back to top | |||
JesuOtaku
ANN Assistant Editor
Posts: 3257 Location: SoCal |
|
||
So it is. Sorry, these things are automatically generated by the encyclopedia, sometimes erroneously. I'll fix it manually. |
|||
Back to top | |||
SkerllyF
Posts: 21 |
|
||
Also I wanna now if the Antimagic LN is better that its anime counterpart? I heard somepeople saying that. Is it true?
|
|||
Back to top | |||
SilverTalon01
Posts: 1218 |
|
||
Personally, I thought the anime was pretty fair in adapting it. Yes, the anime was rushed and loads was cut, but in general what you saw in the anime is what you get with the LNs just with more explanations and more additional scenes. The last arc in the anime had the ending changed compared to the LN. I'm assuming because they know there won't ever be a season 2, they adjusted the anime ending to be less cliffhangery. If you didn't like the characters, story, and setting in the anime, I don't think the LN is going to do much for you. I also have yet to see a case where LN readers have ever said that the LN wasn't better. As an LN reader, I think that is somewhat fair because the anime pretty much always cuts things and certain things might work in written form while coming off awkward in an anime. However, I think there is a lot of undue hatred and bashing on a lot of LN anime just because they didn't perfectly adapt every single thing written in the LN. |
|||
Back to top | |||
Alan45
Village Elder
Posts: 6457 Location: Virginia |
|
||
FilthyCasual wrote:
No, she was more into bondage (with chains). |
|||
Back to top | |||
Hongu
Posts: 7 |
|
||
Ah, I see Aniplex is still paying you guys to shill Asterisk Wars huh?
No way this review is actually serious. Lmao |
|||
Back to top | |||
Anime News Network Forum Index -> Site-related -> Talkback |
All times are GMT - 5 Hours Goto page 1, 2 Next |
|
Page 1 of 2 |
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
⬈
⬋
-
+
Forum
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
Answerman - Why Are UK Releases Slower Than North American Releases?
anime
Christopher asks: I live in the UK and one thing that has been bugging me for a while now is why there is such a big gap in releases of anime Blu-rays/DVDs between US and UK of the same series? One prime example of this is "One Piece". If a series is been released only in the US and not in the UK, that's different. But when the discs is been sold in both countries, why is the UK so far behind our...
Interview: Nami Sano, Author of Haven't You Heard? I'm Sakamoto
manga
The mangaka behind the smash hit comedy Haven't You Heard? I'm Sakamoto speaks out about her influences, how she got her start, and what she thinks of the recent Sakamoto anime!
― Nami Sano, the manga creator of Haven't You Heard? I'm Sakamoto made her first visit to an overseas comics convention at Anime Expo 2016 in Los Angeles earlier this summer, as a guest of BookWalker Global. While she didn't ...
Love Live! The School Idol Movie Premium Edition Blu-Ray
anime
The Love Live movie is finally out on home video, and Nick Creamer has the details on its shiny, sparkly premium edition!
― Love Live! has never been the most emotionally scouring or thematically challenging production. It's grasped at drama, with both of its seasons attempting to top themselves off with some kind of poignant internal dilemma, but these moments are almost uniformly the weakest parts ...
The Best and Worst of the Season So Far: Week of Aug 26-Sep 1
anime
Mob Psycho shoots to the top of the heap, while Re:Zero takes a significant dive from its eight-week streak at the top. Find out where your favorites stack up this week!
― Our team of reviewers are following 30 anime series of the Summer 2016 season and readers are rating each episode as the reviews go up. So let's have a look at what ANN readers consider the best (and worst) of the season. Keep in ...
Komomo Confiserie GN 5
manga
Komomo Confiserie is a nicely compact shojo romance of only five volumes, and this final book wraps things up very sweetly.
― Over the course of its five volumes, Maki Minami's Komomo Confiserie has touched on many of the various tropes that make shoujo manga recognizable – from the abusive love interest to the fanciful fashions to the Cinderella storyline. That in itself isn't particularly remarkabl...
Vice & Luna - #12
just for fun
Vice works out his issues the only way he knows how - with a few too many rounds of Smash Bros!
―
Shelf Life - Punch Line
anime
Paul tumbles down a wormhole of panty panic when faced with the mystery/comedy madness of Punch Line. Plus, all this week's new releases!
― By the time you read this, I'll be on my way home after going on vacation over Labor Day weekend. That means I'm writing this column earlier than usual in order to get it done before I leave, so hello from the distant past! It turns out time travel's easy as lon...
The Asterisk War Novel 1
novels
The first volume of The Asterisk War's original light novel series is a breezy read with more complex characterization than its adaptations. Rebecca Silverman takes a look.
― I suspect that I'm not the only one who is sick of tsunderes, those characters who appear to be prickly and harsh on the outside but have warm, gooey, emotional centers. So it was a pleasant surprise to discover that not only is...
The Mike Toole Show - gdgd Gravy
anime
Mike's attempt at creating his own animation leads him to an encounter with gdgd fairies, one of the strangest cult comedy anime in recent memory.
― Did I ever tell you all how I myself became an animator? It's true! I am totally someone who has made original animation that has appeared on television. If you follow me on twitter or keep tabs on my incessant nerd behavior in general (lately: playing S...
Absolute Duo BD+DVD
anime
It seems like every new season is awash with light novel anime these days, but does Absolute Duo rise above the pack? Theron Martin breaks things down.
― This series' debut last year was not well-received here on ANN; its first episode was one of the lowest-rated of the season amongst ANN staff and readers alike (only World Break and Unlimited Fafnir fared worse), and it did not poll well enough to m...