Forum - View topicShelf Life - Medaka Box
Goto page 1, 2 Next Note: this is the discussion thread for this article |
View previous topic :: View next topic | ||||
Author | Message | |||
---|---|---|---|---|
maximilianjenus
Posts: 917 |
|
|||
I have not watched teh anime, but from your review it looks like it ends before it starts going full meta and becomes even weirder.
|
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
bassgs435
Posts: 149 |
|
|||
spoiler[It ends just when they step out of the elevator and see that Kumagawa has pinned everyone to the walls with screws, so just before the minus arc] |
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
Animegomaniac
Posts: 2333 |
|
|||
Ah, Medaka Box, another victim of the "OMG, our series will be cancelled unless we become a fighting series" editorial technique that plagued a number of WSJ titles. It started as a "we help the hopeless" slice of life parody but it dropped the pretense of liking its audience when it didn't connect. Or is it respecting their intelligence? Anyway, I think of it as the basest form of WSJ audience pandering, the "Isn't it awesome how awesome this all is?" plotting of super empowerment power super battling that got Dragon Ball through arc after arc. DBZ I mean, Dragon Ball was cool. Except for the tournaments.
Ok, I don't know what it exactly became since I dropped it once the characters started to beat the crap out of each other because the WSJ poll declared it necessary- though I don't know why I stuck with DBZ, maybe because it did it first for me. Some later MB plot events I've heard about included multiple character deaths that never stuck and plus, minus or negative student council groups or "Abnormals, Normals and "Specials" people at least tells me that the creators fought to the end to keep the parody elements in it only the audience never got the joke. Wait, I mean "still didn't get the joke". Or did they didn't get it was a joke in the first place? "They meant it that way all along and the opening 13 chapters/9 episodes was just a pretense" is a new one to me though; It doesn't match what I read... a comedic mix of Haruhi Suzumiya and Flunk Punk Rumble... that dropped that in favor of a mess that only kept Medaka as the main character despite being the most unliked part because changing the name of the series would have been too much of a clue of how little their own premise meant to the creators. In short, I know what the Medaka Box was in the slice of life part, a suggestion/help box but did it become something else or was it just an artifact title after the series "got gud"? |
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
Touma
Posts: 2354 Location: Colorado, USA |
|
|||
Thank you for the review of Medaka Box. It was very helpful.
I do not like a show that annoys me for any reason, so I will look elsewhere. Also, the description of how the show changes and what it changes into tells me that it is not for me. If I could borrow this from the library I might watch the first eight episodes, because that part seems like it is my kind of show. I sincerely appreciate the warning, and thanks again for the review. |
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
animalia555
Posts: 438 |
|
|||
|
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
belvadeer
Posts: 2944 |
|
|||
Selector Spread WIXOSS getting its Blu-Ray release is the highlight of this article for me. :D
|
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
Minos_Kurumada
Posts: 41 |
|
|||
How cute, you think Medaka Box takes 9 episodes to explain what it's about.
Wahahaha.... man, this damn thing changes focus and genera each 25 chapters or so and was 100% self-conscious of it, in one chapter the main villain of the time smashes the 4th wall, turns to the reader and declares: "This shitty fighting Manga will transform in a shitty love comedy from the next chapter on".
This is the funny part: Nisio Isin (Monogatari series) and Medaka box's writer realized this too. So what he did being the kind of guy he is? He transformed MB in a deconstruction of WSJ antics, he directly transformed Medaka into a tragic hero trapped by the Shounen Jump hero oath of "I live for those who I love happiness" he transform this in something negative and explores what actually would happen if somebody actually only cared for others happiness while neglecting her own. Nisio Isin even craps on WSJ famous motto: "Friendship, Hardwork and Victory!" stating that "What Shounen Manga teaches it's not Friendship, Hardwork and Victory! but, that only those with Power are the ones that win at the end, it's the pinnacle of cruel realities". Medaka Box it's, ironically, obligatory read for those who hate WSJ. |
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
Calsolum
Posts: 405 |
|
|||
hmn i think annoying is a bit strong of a word but i do understand how it can definitely put off some. For instance alot of people i know love Jojojo for its over the top hammyness but i just had to sign off after Dio spoiler[becomes a vampire]. May watch the other arcs since I've heard that was the weakest of them all. If you can grab the manga I highly recommend it cause its a great series and it has a tendency of acknowledging most shonnen tropes then either subverting or turning it up to 11. Once you understand what youre in for and you like it youre in for an incredible ride. |
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
Heishi
Posts: 166 |
|
|||
I dunno about you guys, but Medaka is really attractive for a blue haired female character.
|
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
thekingsdinner
Posts: 658 Location: Terheijden, Netherlands |
|
|||
I always forget Medaka Box exists. Watched about 4 episodes back when it aired, but I remember absolutely nothing about it.
Soul Hunter looks right up my alley though. Will look into that one. |
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
jymmy
Posts: 1110 |
|
|||
Not really: she battles spoiler[Akira again, one new Selector and has a high-stakes WIXOSS battle with someone who isn't a Selector]. |
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
GVentola
Posts: 14 |
|
|||
So, I guess this means no third series after Medaka Box Abnormal? And it left off on a cliffhanger! It'd be nice if someone could tell me what happens in the manga (supposing the manga and anime mirror one another). Maybe I can get some closure!
|
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
Via_01
Posts: 523 |
|
|||
The manga itself left a big impression on me because, as someone else said, it's pretty much a very different take on the WSJ formula. Several shonen staples become interesting plot points, such as "the main character HAS to win in the end", "any heavily-designed character MUST be of some importance", "powers NEED to grow bigger and more complicated", etc.
As an example (for those who don't mind minor spoilers), spoiler[one character gets an ability called Devil's Luck, which basically disconnects him from the narrative conventions of the shonen genre: he won't miraculously survive a fatal wound, he won't be there to save the day at the right time, but at the very least, he'll have a chance at beating the main character, because there's no longer anything dictating that the main character must win.] The show itself looked fairly bland to me, though the action direction was pretty nice. It's clear that they stopped caring by season 2, as both the animation and the pacing took a big blow to the gut. |
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
meiam
Posts: 1209 |
|
|||
Yeah I'd be incredibly surprised if the shift to battle format was planned, having read the manga it very clearly came off as a last ditch effort to avoid cancelation.
It wasn't particularly good either, it's pretty vanilla as far as shonen goes. Ended up dropping it pretty quickly at that point. |
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
killjoy_the
Posts: 1101 |
|
|||
Medaka Box is my favorite manga and possibly one of my least liked adaptations. It lacked... well, everything. I didn't find the animation nice at all - the art style is very sharp and simplifying it takes a real toll on it. Plus, I quite remember the "two people kicking air directly in front of the other for 2 minutes while a monologue happens" scene. The one and only scene I can think of where the anime elevated the base material was with the "...so I'll kill you" monologue. The music was so bland I don't remember anything about it, including OPs and EDs, most of the characters voices just felt wrong somehow (I always imagine Medaka having a really strong voice, ala Kill la Kill's Satsuki), the pacing taken was kind of bad (stretching the mostly-fluff beginning and sort of rushing the Abnormal plot), but then again considering how long the Minus arc takes they couldn't do much. The last episode is good, if only because Kumagawa's always one hell of an entertaining bastard to watch/read, but it's not like it makes sense for an anime-only watcher and neither like you need to watch the rest of the anime to enjoy it if you've read the manga.
|
||||
Back to top |
|
|||
Anime News Network Forum Index -> Site-related -> Talkback |
All times are GMT - 5 Hours Goto page 1, 2 Next |
|
Page 1 of 2 |
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
⬈
⬋
-
+
Forum
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
Answerman - How Much Anime Can REALLY Fit On A Blu-ray?
anime
Some anime come with 13 episodes (or more) crammed on a single bluray disc - is that really enough space to maintain HD picture quality? Justin gets into it.
― Mike (Toole) asks: How much anime will fit on a single Blu-Ray disc? Is a single BD-50 really enough for 13 episodes of subtitled 1080p anime? How much anime can comfortably fit onto a dual layer Blu-ray in full HD? For those who don't know, ...
Shelf Life - Aquarion Evol
anime
James dives into the wacky, innuendo-filled world of Aquarion Evol and does his best to make sense of it all. Plus, all this week's new releases!
― I spent about twenty bucks on an anime figure last week (Eli from Love Live, in case you're wondering), and now I'm fighting to hold myself back from buying more. I used to buy figures on a regular basis, and nothing quite beats that initial thrill of se...
Please tell me! Galko-chan Episodes 1-12 Streaming
anime
Rose Bridges takes a look at this underrated short gag series from earlier in the year and discovers a surprisingly educational (and filthy) anime like nothing else out there.
― When I was in high school, there was one huge girls' bathroom in the main hallway. For some reason, there was no such equivalent for the guys. This place became a sort of social gathering spot for all the girls in school, reg...
The List - 6 Strange Reinterpretations of Classic Literature
anime
Legends never die, and old stories can always be made new again. Just add robots! Here are a few strange anime takes on memorable classic tales.
― Classic literature is a resource regularly mined for new visual adaptations, whether it's a Jane Austen romance or another mystery starring the unflappable Sherlock Holmes. These stories and their characters are immediately familiar to audiences around th...
Nisekoi 2 Sub.Blu-Ray 2
anime
Nisekoi's second season comes to a close with no romantic resolution in sight, but is the journey more important than the destination? Theron Martin investigates.
― This release covers the second half of the series – episodes 7-12. This run of episodes is average by franchise standards, including both the weakest entries of the season and one of the strongest. Aside from a sad magical girl parody don...
Answerman - Do Salarymen Really Read Manga?
manga
Most anime may not be as mainstream in Japan as we would like to believe, but what about manga? Does the average working adult really read comics on the train?
― Vithuyan asks: I have heard that manga is very popular among salary-men in Japan, is that true? Yes. Although most of them are not reading Shonen Jump. Seinen manga magazines ("seinen" literally means youth, but in terms of manga demographi...
ANNCast - A Thousand Miles
anime
Zac and Jacob welcome Crunchyroll brand manager Miles Thomas to goof around for an entire hour about Danganronpa, Orange, Re:Zero, cake vs pastry donuts and much much more!
― ANNCast Episode 270: A Thousand Miles Zac and Jacob welcome Crunchyroll brand manager Miles Thomas to goof around for an entire hour about Danganronpa, Orange, Re:Zero, cake vs pastry donuts and much much more! You can listen t...
Interview: Knights of Sidonia Mangaka Tsutomu Nihei
manga
Deeply influential sci-fi mangaka Tsutomu Nihei talks about his incredible career, and goes in-depth about his most famous creations: Knights of Sidonia and Blame!
― Mecha suits, space motorcycles, morphing space aliens, epic futuristic cities, and talking bears with guns – this and more are the product of the imagination of manga artist Tsutomu Nihei. The creator of mind-bending science fiction seri...
First Impressions: Attack on Titan: Wings of Freedom (PS4)
games
Eren and his Titan-killing pals finally arrive in proper videogame form, with the thrilling ability to zip around on your very own 3D Maneuver gear - but is the rest of the game worth the hype?
― It's been a few years since monster-killing mega-franchise Attack on Titan hit critical mass, and now Tecmo Koei's flagship development team, Omega Force, has been put to the test to deliver an Attack on Tit...
That Wolf-Boy is Mine! GN 1
manga
This first volume of Yoko Nagiri's supernatural shojo story is a cut above the pack thanks to its thoughtful take on old tropes. Rebecca Silverman takes a closer look.
― Literature is rife with mildly embarrassing titles obscuring really enjoyable books – just look at the romance section of any bookstore. Yoko Nagiri's That Wolf-Boy is Mine joins their ranks with this first volume. Despite its title,...