American officials, several of their allies and many U.S. media
criticized Philippine President Gloria Macapagal Arroyo's decision to recall
her nation's small military contingent in Iraq in order to save the life of
Filipino hostage Angelo dela Cruz. They called the move cowardly and said it
sent terrorists "the wrong signal."
For most of dela Cruz's compatriots, however, and from the standpoint of
their national interest, it was a sensible, even courageous move. There was
more at stake in Arroyo's decision to pull out of Iraq than saving the life of
an unfortunate hostage or avoiding the ire of the U.S. government, a key
source of foreign aid for the Philippines. The hostage crisis imperiled a
crucial survival mechanism for the impoverished nation -- the gainful
employment of millions of overseas Filipino workers in the Middle East. Some 2
million Filipinos work in the region, with nearly a million in Saudi Arabia
alone, according to the Philippine Department of Foreign Affairs.
These large contingents of Filipino workers have become a critical prop
of the Philippine economy. They represent the millions who can't find work in
their own country. They send home some $8 billion a year (remittances were
largely responsible for a 4.5 percent GNP growth in 2002), providing otherwise
income-strapped families the spending power that keeps the economy afloat. A
number of Filipinos have been among the unintended victims of suicide bombings
in Israel, and a number were killed in recent attacks on foreigners working
for American firms in Saudi Arabia.
For Arroyo to insist on remaining in the so-called "coalition of the
willing," despite the terrorists' threats, would have exposed all Filipinos in
the region to a dramatically higher level of danger -- where they are
transformed into deliberate targets of terror because their government
persists in giving political cover to Bush's "coalition" by keeping a symbolic
military contingent in Iraq.
In such an eventuality, the mass return of millions of Filipino workers
evading terrorist attacks in the Middle East would mean disaster for the
Philippine economy. The Philippine government is simply not prepared to absorb
a sudden influx of jobless returnees. The large-scale repatriation of
Filipinos from the Middle East also would mean trouble for many Arab countries
-- including some of America's allies -- that have come to depend on
imported Filipino labor or expertise for a multitude of tasks, from domestic
work to construction and management. There can be no doubt that President
Arroyo's decision to pull out of Iraq to protect other Filipinos was quietly
encouraged by many an Arab host government.
Clearly, Arroyo's decision was also politically self-serving, given the
popular outcry for dela Cruz's safe return. Overseas Filipino workers -- an
estimated 8 million labor in 150 countries -- risk their lives and endure
long absences from their families. They're often called modern-day heroes by
Filipino officials and media alike. In 1995, President Fidel Ramos' popularity
plunged when he failed to save the life of Flor Contemplacion, a domestic
worker who was hanged by the government of Singapore on a questionable murder
conviction. Dela Cruz's kidnapping brought back memories of that execution,
and the political danger was not lost on Arroyo. She had just assumed office
after a bitter election whose credibility is held in doubt. Failure to bring
back dela Cruz alive would have given her enemies effective ammunition in a
poisonous political climate rife with talk of destabilization plots.
For most Filipino opinion-makers -- and from the standpoint of the
Philippines' national interest -- pulling out of Iraq was not a "wrong
signal" to terrorists. The wrong signal was to send a troop contingent to
begin with, which only served to militarize the longstanding and purely
civilian Filipino presence in the Middle East and made it a likely target of
terrorist attacks.
As for Washington's implied threat of leaving the Philippines at the
mercy of its homegrown terrorists, it's empty and face-saving. The Philippines
remains the most important staging area for U.S. operations against al Qaeda's
affiliates in Southeast Asia, as predominantly Muslim Indonesia and Malaysia
are less than ideal hosts. In fact, several U.S. military exercises are set to
take place in Southern Philippines. Like it or not, Washington is stuck with
Manila, and Manila knows it.
This article appeared on page B - 7 of the San Francisco Chronicle
more