(Go: >> BACK << -|- >> HOME <<)

Nick Clegg's first day – as it happened

Haroon Siddique with minute-by-minute coverage of Nick Clegg's Q&A session at MSN's offices in London

Nick Clegg on 16 August 2010.
Nick Clegg today. Photograph: Tim Ireland/PA

10.27am: Even if Nick Clegg is not officially in charge – David Cameron has insisted he remains the boss while on holiday – the Liberal Democrat leader will be keen to demonstrate his prime ministerial qualities over the next fortnight, beginning today. The coalition government has not been kind to the Lib Dems so far, with the party's popularity and that of Clegg floundering.

A Downing Street spokesman played down Clegg's role while Cameron is at the seaside, commenting: "Nick will be around and picking up some events." But for Clegg the next two weeks could be key to trying to turn around the fortunes of his party and how he as an individual is viewed within the coalition government.

First on the agenda today, at 11.30am, is a "virtual town hall" Q&A at the offices of MSN in London. You can put your questions to Nick Clegg by emailing asknickclegg@live.co.uk or on Twitter by using the #asknickclegg hashtag. More details of how you can submit questions can be found here.

I'll be following today's events as Clegg, the man the Mail on Sunday yesterday called "probably the most leftwing person ever to hold such high office [by standing in as PM]", takes charge ... sort of.

10.57am: Many of the today's papers preview Clegg "taking charge". The Daily Mail says he faces a "coalition backlash", citing the comments of Lib Dem deputy leader Simon Hughes, who has ruled out the prospect of any electoral pact with the Tories at the next general election. The Mail writes that at the Q&A today "Clegg will argue that the Lib Dems have been able to push for radical political reforms – including plans for the referendum [on changing the voting system] – only because they are in government."

The Times also refers to Hughes's comments and "tensions" within the coalition. It says:

Live blog: quote

Clegg will spend much of the next two weeks trying to resolve outstanding spending rows. They include an argument between the Treasury and the Ministry of Defence over who pays for Trident, the nuclear deterrent.

There are cold crumbs of comfort for those who believe the Lib Dem leader has sold the party's soul to the right in the Daily Telegraph's assertion that Clegg will "push the government to the left as he takes charge". The paper says:

Live blog: quote

He will use his fortnight at the helm to promote his party's pet policies, such as electoral reform and social equality.

The Telegraph describes the unveiling of former Labour cabinet minister Alan Milburn as the government's new social mobility tsar as the "centrepiece" of Clegg's week.

11.10am: If there are tensions within the coalition, and more pointedly within the Liberal Democrat party itself, an analysis in the Liberal magazine is likely to pour fuel on the fire. Simon Kovar writes that the party leadership's has neglected its political and philosophical traditions, thus creating "the neo-Liberal Democrats". Kovar writes:

Live blog: quote

Successive generations of Liberal Democrat leaders and politicians, whether of the party's left or right, have held the following in common. They have fought privilege and corruption; they have argued for a redistribution of wealth and opportunity from the rich to the poor; they have regarded the market as a (limited) means and not an (un-checked) end; and they have recognised the moral limits of markets. They have argued in support of public services and, when they have spoken of public service reform, they have meant alternative means of public provision, not privatisation. They have regarded proportional representation as the absolute precondition of a more pluralist and cooperative politics. And they have argued for a realignment of the left. Every one of these commitments has been abandoned by Nick Clegg.

11.25am: The Clegg Q&A is due to start shortly. It is being streamed live on the No 10 website.

Nick Clegg in a live Q&A at MSN's offices in London on 16 August 2010. Clegg at the Q&A; today.

11.34am: Clegg has begun speaking.

11.41am: First question: what have been the highlights and lowlights of the coalition so far and how long will it last?

It will last five years, Clegg says. Parliamentary terms shouldn't be the plaything of the prime minister.

Live blog: quote

We need five years to sort things out ... We have to take a lot of very difficult decisions.

Clegg says there are "glimmers" of good news.

The highlights are the creation of the coalition itself, he says. It's a government that "has a very strong sense of purpose". The government has legislated for important changes in education. Plans for political reform are his third highlight.

Clegg doesn't name any specific lowlights.

11.46am: Q: Are the cuts too harsh?

A: "You have to do it...there's no easy way out of this." Clegg refers to problems in Greece and Spain and says it is "morally wrong" to hand over debt from one generation to the next.
Clegg says the coalition has shown its commitment to fairness. He cites the raising of the personal allowance and the increasing of capital gains tax and refers to the "triple lock" designed to protect the value of pensions.

11.47am: Q: What are we going to do to get banks lending?

A: "It's arguably one of the greatest restraints on recovery of the British economy," Clegg says. It is clearly not right when small and medium-sized businesses are crying out for credit and not getting it.

11.48am: Q: What's going to happen about businesses being over-regulated?

A: Clegg refers to the coalition's one-in, one-out rule – whenever a new regulation is brought in, an existing one will be scrapped.

11.50am: A 16-year-old asks when she is going to get the vote.

Clegg says he personally supports 16-year-olds getting the vote but it was not part of the coalition agreement. The case has become stronger over time, he says; it shouldn't be a party political issue. It's a debate that should be had.

11.53am: Q: How will voting reform strengthen our democracy? How much will the referendum on changing the voting system cost?

A: The vote will cost £80m to £100m but there are also reforms to reduce the number of MPs which would save money. The alternative vote electoral system (which the government wants to put to a referendum next May) provides more choice by ranking candidates in order. It offers more choice and control.

The live feed fails on Nick Clegg's MSN Q&A

Anyone trying to follow the feed on the Downing Street website will have trouble: Clegg's microphone is crackly and almost inaudible. But at least they've got a feed: here's a screenshot of the MSN page.

11.58am: Q: What is Britain doing to help those affected by floods in Pakistan and why is it not doing more?

A: A quarter of the aid donated by the international community so far has come from Britain. The response from some sections of the international community has been "lamentable", Clegg says. He says people are struggling to grasp the extent of the damage inflicted, maybe because the damage is underwater. Britain has allocated £30m so far and is taking a lead in the international effort.

Video: Nick Clegg calls response to Pakistan floods 'lamentable' Link to this video

11.59am: Q: Would you like to hear more from the country on their ideas on what they could do? (The type of question the Cabinet Office would love to have planted ... )

A: Clegg refers to the online forum where members of the public can make suggestions to the government. He also refers to the website where people can suggest rules to be abolished.

12.01pm: Q: Shouldn't we be going after tax avoiders and evaders?

A: Tax is too complex and has become a "paradise" for lawyers helping their clients to reduce their tax bills.

12.02pm: Q: You're acting prime minister; what are you going to be doing this week?

Clegg laughs. He is "holding the fort" but is not acting prime minister – seems like a fine line.

He's asked if he could imagine himself in this position a few months ago. "No," he replies to laughter.

12.05pm: Clegg is taking questions from the audience now.

Q: How have house prices risen so much and does it matter that they are so high?

A: It's heartbreaking that people can't find homes they can afford. Housing policy has been too centralised.

12.08pm: Q: How is it fair on taxpayers if more money is going to pensioners who are not contributing under the triple-lock guarantee?

A: Clegg says the policy is morally right and pensioners have contributed all their life. He says he disagrees with the questioner referring to them not contributing.

12.12pm: Q: Isn't the VAT increase going to hit poor people the hardest?

A: We looked at many different ways of avoiding this, Clegg says. He thinks Labour is saying we have to do it but not now. You can't "duck" difficult decisions by not doing them now, he says. Apart from referring to maintaining zero-rated products he makes no reference to the impact on the poorest sections of society.

12.12pm: Q: What should happen about Trident?

A: The equipment for troops on the frontline should be the priority. Clegg says his views on Trident are well-known and there is high-tech equipment that is no longer relevant to current warfare.

12.13pm: Q: When will we be withdrawing from Afghanistan?

A: There is a pledge to leave by 2015 but he would like them to come back as soon as possible without jeopardising the mission. "I want them to come back with their heads held high," Clegg says. The acid test is the stability of the country.

12.14pm: Q: Is it going to be any easier to find an NHS dentist?

A: The NHS budget is being protected to allow people to gain access to services.

12.15pm: Q: Are mixed-sex wards being scrapped (as was reported today)?

A: We are going to change it and Andrew Lansley will make a detailed announcement tomorrow.

12.17pm: Q: What's your favourite biscuit?

A: If dunked rich tea, if not HobNobs. "That's what it's about being in charge for two weeks." Whoops, Freudian slip?

12.18pm: Q: What is the commitment to creativity in the UK (with reference to the arts)?

A: Where the government can't carry on giving money, we're trying to encourage philanthropists and donations from the national lottery fund.

12.19pm: Q: Are cuts to the police force the right thing to do given crime and anti-social behaviour?

Clegg repeats the Tory-Lib Dem mantra of getting more officers out on the streets and not stuck behind desks.

12.22pm: Q: What would success mean at the end of the five-year parliament?

A: The economy would be growing again, we would not be relying on any particular sector for growth. We would be a greener nation with more freedom.

12.24pm: Clegg is asked about the water summit he is attending as part of the UN Millennium Development Goals programme.

The government will continue to meet its promises on international development despite the recession. He will "continue to beat the drum" for those goals, he says.

12.26pm: Q: Should conscription be introduced?

A: No, says Clegg. He refers to "some of the things we've introduced" to get young people involved but does not seem to have the same passion as Cameron about the Tory leader's vision of a army of volunteers, part of his "big society" scheme.

12.28pm: Q: What will former Labour minister Alan Milburn be doing in his new role working with the government?

A: He will not be part of government, he will be an independent reviewer on social mobility. We've got to remove barriers to social mobility. Clegg hopes there will be an annual debate on how to increase social mobility.

12.31pm: Q: What level is acceptable for immigration and is there too much?

A: There is no magic number, says Clegg. But he then refers to the upper limit in the coalition agreement – not very convincing. I've always argued for a fair system and for proper policing of our borders, he says.

And that was the final question of the session.

12.44pm: It wasn't the Clegg who everyone agreed with after the first election leaders' debate but equally it wasn't the Clegg who blundered in parliament when referring to the "illegality" of the Iraq war. He looked strangely nervous at the start; maybe it was the enormity of being in charge (or not). But he was soon out of his chair waving his arms about. Oddly, his biggest stumble seemed to be when he was asked to name his favourite biscuit and initially confused his preferred "dunker" with his favourite "non-dunker". During the same answer he also referred to being in charge after earlier rubbishing the reports that he was acting PM. Perhaps that was the hardest question because most of the others required him to do little than trot out the coalition line. He seemed to become most animated on Pakistan, criticising the "lamentable" international response to the floods. He also seemed passionate about plans to improve social mobility, and confirmed government plans to end mixed-sex wards. But it is unlikely there was anything there that will have changed anyone's perception of Clegg on either side of the debate. The outsider status that served him so well in opposition is now but a distant memory ...

2.15pm: Michael White was at the Q&A session and has filed a blogpost here.

He notes:

Michael White Michael White. Photograph: Linda Nylind

The Lib Dem leader and deputy prime minister hasn't had the practice – or the exposure – that David Cameron has had, and it shows.

His answers are more hesitant, less polished and more prone to safe generalisation, though that's understandable after his being hammered for "gaffes" like his assertion that the Iraq war was illegal. It's a point of view, widely held, but not what you're meant to say in coalition with a party that disagrees.


Your IP address will be logged

Comments in chronological order

Comments are now closed for this entry.
  • This symbol indicates that that person is The Guardian's staffStaff
  • This symbol indicates that that person is a contributorContributor

Showing first 50 comments | Go to all comments | Go to latest comment

  • RedRush RedRush

    16 Aug 2010, 10:47AM

    There is always mention of a Downing Street spokesperson who is this individual? Is it Gaby Bertin, Cameron's Press Secretary?

    I suppose anything other than EDL, BNP and UKIP would be seen as the Daily Mail as left wing

  • RedRush RedRush

    16 Aug 2010, 11:05AM

    Substantive policy issue: inequality. How is the Codem policy programme going to address this.

    Unsubstantive policy announcement Alan Milburn in government - Social mobility tsar? I don't think feudal Russia did a lot for the mobility of the peasantry. Is it a sign of things to come?

    Regional policy being proposed totally flawed.
    Educational policy - likely to create more inequality
    Cuts programme to House bulding, local housing allowance and job seekers allowance - full of unintended consequences.
    Scrapping the Audit Commission - will mask the running down of local services
    VAT increase - will further socio-economic inequality

    If Cleggaron could answer any of the following I'd be mightyly inpressed.

  • MindOverMatter MindOverMatter

    16 Aug 2010, 11:07AM

    @GlennOlive

    I'm greatly looking forward to the measured and completely impartial responses you will give to any negative views expressed on "The Great Leader", and his radical new blue agenda..

  • Gordi Gordi

    16 Aug 2010, 11:09AM

    "There are cold crumbs of comfort for those who believe the Lib Dem leader has sold the party's soul to the right in the Daily Telegraph's assertion that Clegg will "push the government to the left as he takes charge".

    Are you serious? In the first 100 days he has been incapable of doing that. What makes him think he will do it in two weeks?

    Or maybe ...while the cat's away the mice will misbehave!

  • RedRush RedRush

    16 Aug 2010, 11:22AM

    Some pointed questions needed on Environmental policy and the promise to be the greenest government of its generation are due.

    I hear the proposed Energy Bill first referred to as the Energy Security and Green Energy Bill will be consigned to the dustbin.

    On top of that there is a proposed sell off, of English and Welsh environmental assets

  • ninjawarrior ninjawarrior

    16 Aug 2010, 11:28AM

    here we go again ..the desperate Guardian trying to find something , anything will do, to try to prise apart the Coalition . Desperate indeed . Has Clegg told you he is "in charge of the cvountry- sort-of " is are these the musings of a sad , story-seeking (creating?) journalist ? Its hilarious !! Keep up the comedy show, Guardian - you begin to appear more and more ridiculous.

  • rsc82 rsc82

    16 Aug 2010, 11:41AM

    You got 2 weeks to get drug-policy reform done....

    GO!

    Just come back from Canada where everyone smokes weed, couldn't have been a nicer atmosphere to be honest. Do it Clegg, do it now!

  • Cuse Cuse

    16 Aug 2010, 11:45AM

    Clegg. I take you very seriously indeed, so I'm going to give you some targets.

    If you answer any question directly today I will forgo coleslaw on my regular Monday turkey, ham + coleslaw sandwich.

    Every time you mention "the new politics", "progressive", "tribal" or "radical" I will kill a ladybird.

    You have a limit of 2 mentions of the defecit. Any more uses - especially if you invoke the phrase "Labour's cuts", and I will drive to London, find you and politely request that you desist.

    Haroon - help me to keep tabs on the super-serious Cleggie.

  • RogerOThornhill RogerOThornhill

    16 Aug 2010, 11:47AM

    @ninjawarrior

    Did you miss this bit on one of the links?

    "The PM remains in charge but while he's on holiday Nick will be around and picking up some events," a Downing Street spokesman said.

    So Nick is 'in charge..sort of' then isn't he?

    as Clegg, the man the Mail on Sunday yesterday called "probably the most leftwing person ever to hold such high office [by standing in as PM]"

    Erm...Atlee? I know the Mail's history is pretty shaky these days but even so.

  • padav padav

    16 Aug 2010, 11:48AM

    @RedRush: Regional policy being proposed totally flawed.

    errrr........what Regional policy might that be?

    The Conservative's (being the dominant Coalition partner) approach to anything Regional seems akin to a scorched earth policy, identify any insitution or policy initiative displaying a "Regional" label and either abolish it / remove the funding stream, which amounts to the same end result.

    Of course this search and destroy strategy only applies to England; if you live in Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland the established nature of your devolved tiers of accountable governance provides a measure of defence against such strictures - the fact that Greater London, to take one obvious example, exceeds all three of these sub-UK geo-political territories, in terms of population size and GDP, seems to have escaped the Conservative's reasoning (if that's the right word to use) processes?

  • houses houses

    16 Aug 2010, 11:54AM

    Vote Clegg to privatise the NHS and let the bankers off the hook.

    Cameron has persuaded Clegg to see what he terms the light. Cleggeron light is very dark.

  • Spikediswhack Spikediswhack

    16 Aug 2010, 11:54AM

    Q: What are we going to do to get banks lending?

    A: "It's arguably one of the greatest restraints on recovery of the British economy," Clegg says. It is clearly not right when small and medium-sized businesses are crying out for credit and not getting it.

    That's not really an answer is it? If I went to the doctor and asked what he would do about my broken leg and all he said was 'well, a broken leg can be quite a problem, you won't be able to walk' and did nothing about it then I'd think he or she was a pretty rubbish doctor.

  • LoveLondon LoveLondon

    16 Aug 2010, 11:57AM

    Two weeks to implement the Liberal Democrat Manifesto before Cameron returns. Quick rush rush. I can just imagine Cameron's face when he returns to the new Liberal Democrat country.

    Cameron: Has anything happen whilst I was away

    Clegg: Yes we've joined the Euro

  • fibmac70 fibmac70

    16 Aug 2010, 11:59AM

    The Telegraph describes the unveiling of former Labour cabinet minister Alan Milburn as the government's new social mobility tsar as the "centrepiece" of Clegg's week

    'Tsar' and 'social mobility' sit as uneasily together
    As Fuhrer and socialism, or 'Liberal party' and 'Leader'

  • cowmonkey cowmonkey

    16 Aug 2010, 12:00PM

    ninjawarrior

    16 Aug 2010, 11:28AM

    here we go again ..the desperate Guardian trying to find something , anything will do, to try to prise apart the Coalition . Desperate indeed . Has Clegg told you he is "in charge of the cvountry- sort-of "

    What a load of piffle. Do you actually pay attention to politics, or do you prefer to spout illogical guff at the earliest opportunity?

    Traditionally, when the PM goes on holiday, the deputy is nominally in charge, albeit without any actual powers. No. 10 have briefed journalists to say Deputy PM Clegg is not running the country. It's not The Guardian who are trying to 'prise apart the coalition', nor is it No. 10. The Daily Mail were ones the who said Clegg was in charge - Andrew was merely commenting that he's not really. As per the No. 10 briefing.

  • Gordi Gordi

    16 Aug 2010, 12:00PM

    About us being in charge to sack our MPs. Can I start by sacking you and Cameron before you wreck the country? If I can do that, then I would really believe in your "new politics".

  • sereinfalls sereinfalls

    16 Aug 2010, 12:01PM

    Cameron: Has anything happen whilst I was away

    Clegg: Yes I have implemented all our election promises

    Cameron: REALLY!

    Clegg: No just kidding. Can I get you a nice cup of tea?

    Cameron: Oh thank goodness for that, yes please tea would be wonderful

    Both laugh like small children as they slip into a hot soapy bath together.....

  • RedRush RedRush

    16 Aug 2010, 12:03PM

    @ padav

    Your right regional policy is based on a scourched earth approach, If you've read the laughable paper Clegg published a couple of months ago there is more cause for concern. A £1billion fund for all regions designed to rebalance the share of public and priavte sector jobs. Total rubbish as a policy £1Bn for a 2 year programme designed to address vital infrastructure issues would just about pay for Wembley Stadium let alone address the north south divide.

    This was Cleggs offer to the electorate and what Vince had been working on in Ministry he argued had no reason to exist. The first question in the consultation on Clegg's reguional growth fund did'nt make sense. The argument for the programme said parts of the country e.g. North East had over 50% public sector employed in work compared to London's 36%. It then followed that London would bid for this fund - if you follow the theory then surely these disparities would be widended.

    So far the Coalition has delivered a lot of double talk - Big Society to ruse to save money is flimsy. If your your for the Big Society why withdraw voluntary and community sector programmes designed to help the Big Society. None of the policies have been cleared tried and tested and the biggest one of all the economic policies are based on a form of casino capitalism - where are the 2million new jobs going to come when help to get people into work is absent

  • FrancyPants FrancyPants

    16 Aug 2010, 12:04PM

    12.01pm: Q: Shouldn't we be going after tax avoiders and evaders?

    A: Tax is too complex and has become a "paradise" for lawyers helping their clients to reduce their tax bills.

    So is that a no then?

  • Parvulesco Parvulesco

    16 Aug 2010, 12:06PM

    If Clegg is the 'alternative', bring Brown back!

    Agreed.

    It was nice having someone with an intellect and an iota of moral rectitude running the joint (even if he wasn't sufficiently touchy-feely with the punters) wasn't it?

  • johnnyrotten johnnyrotten

    16 Aug 2010, 12:07PM

    What colour is he? he has sold his principles so many times already he has more colours than a rainbow.

    Hey this is the NEW politics, you can change your principles every day as long as you are being "pragmatic" and "progressive".

  • Bobbyb71 Bobbyb71

    16 Aug 2010, 12:08PM

    GlennOlive
    16 Aug 2010, 10:55AM

    I'm greatly looking forward to the mature and rational discussions about substantive policy issues which will fill this thread.

    Well if you're looking for people to praise Clegg you have a wide range of media outlets to choose from.

    Newspapers - Mail. Telegraph, Express, Sun, The Times. Guardian etc
    or on TV - Sky News, BBC News, ITV news.

    You're spoilt for choice really.

  • RedRush RedRush

    16 Aug 2010, 12:09PM

    Q: How have house prices risen so much and does it matter that they are so high?

    A: It's heartbreaking that people can't find homes they can afford. Housing policy has been too centralised.

    This event is utterly rubbish for generating discussion on subtantive policy matters .

    Just read his answer to the housing question (above) and he's just trotted out a throw away line about centralised policy.

    They have no ideas or real answers

  • frog2 frog2

    16 Aug 2010, 12:11PM

    Has anyone asked the vital question, pointing out that re-distribution of income and wealth has been going systematically upwards for the past thirty years in the 'developed world ' ?

    If Mr Clegg agrees that that is the proven case, as it is !, what is he going to do about it ?

  • Bobbyb71 Bobbyb71

    16 Aug 2010, 12:16PM

    Kerfuffling
    16 Aug 2010, 12:12PM

    Wow. This is really getting to the heart of the problems we face. Decisive stuff.

    Oh, no sorry was watching Cbeebies.

    Yes. I noticed the talking animals on Cbeebies 'Big Barn Farm' discussing a much more coherent housing policy than Clegg.

    Clegg as always seems empty in ideas and undersatnding

  • Rainborough Rainborough

    16 Aug 2010, 12:18PM

    Someone should ask Clegg if he will consider himself a failure or a success if, as seems highly likely, the coalition ends its term with the gap between rich and poor even higher than under New Labour.

Showing first 50 comments | Go to all comments | Go to latest comment

Comments are now closed for this entry.

Comments

Sorry, commenting is not available at this time. Please try again later.

Our selection of best buys

Lender Initial rate
First Direct 2.99% More
HSBC 2.99% More
HSBC 2.19% More
Name BT Rate BT Period
NatWest Platinum 0% 16 mths More
Royal Bank of Scotland Platinum 0% 16 mths More
Barclaycard Platinum 0% 15 mths More
Provider Typical APR
Santander Personal Loan 7.8% More
Alliance & Leicester Personal Loan 7.8% More
Sainsbury's Personal Loan 7.8% More

Find your MP

Latest news on guardian.co.uk

Guardian Bookshop

This week's bestsellers

  1. 1.  American Caesars

    by Nigel Hamilton £25.00

  2. 2.  Third Man

    by Peter Mandelson £25.00

  3. 3.  Punishment of Gaza

    by Gideon Levy £8.99

  4. 4.  What If Latin America Ruled the World?

    by Oscar Guardiola-Rivera £20.00

  5. 5.  Nothing to Envy

    by Barbara Demick £8.99

Browse all jobs

jobs by Indeed

More from Politics live with Andrew Sparrow