(Go: >> BACK << -|- >> HOME <<)



Archive for December, 2004

h1

Our Election Prediction Competition

Thursday, December 30th, 2004

    Something more to argue about

New Year’s Eve and a good moment to launch our General Election Prediction Competition. Apart from the honour and the recognition from your peers we are hoping that a sponsor will provide a suitable prize. At the moment the best we have got is a colour picture of Ken Livingstone with his autograph on it and a Tony Blair mug where the nose grows as you pour in hot water.

  • Post your entries as a comment by the end of next Saturday - January 7 2005.
  • Please do not use the comments section here for anything other than entries. Discussion on the competition should be on the previous thread
  • Copy and paste the list below and type in your predictions accordingly.
  • Please include a valid email address and only one entry is allowed per person.
  • My decision on all matters relating to the competition is final.
  • 1. Size of the Labour majority/minority. Fifteen points for getting it right reducing by one point either side for each seat off target.

    2. Size of Labour’s lead/deficit in the GB popular vote in percentage points. Ten points for getting it right reducing by one point either way for each 0.25% off target.

    3. Most accurate pollster. This will be decided on the size of the predicted Lab-Con margin based on their final surveys. Choose one from ICM, Mori, NOP, CR, or YouGov. Four points for winner. Two points for second.

    4. Winning party Bethnal Green and Bow. Two points.

    5. Winning party Bristol West Two points.

    6. Winning party Cambridge Two points.

    7. Winning party Colne Valley Two points.

    8. Winning party Inverness Two points.

    9. Winning party Maidenhead Two points.

    10. Winning party St. Albans Two points.

    11. Winning party Upper Bann Two points.

    12. Winning party Ynys Mon Two points.

    Thanks to all who have provided ideas for which seats to choose. Best of luck and a happy New Year.

    Mike Smithson



    h1

    Help wanted - General Election Competition

    Thursday, December 30th, 2004

    I am compiling a General Election Prediction competition which as well as the general forecasts has six or seven seat specific elements.

    At the moment I’ve got Bethnal Green & Bow (George Galloway); Cambridge (the most discussed seat on the site) ; Dorset West (Oliver Letwin’s and a LD decapitation target) ; Brent East (by-election follow-up) and St. Albans (possible tactical vote unwind) .

    I’d like interesting Scottish and Welsh seats as well as any other suggestions for seats that represent a type.

    This will go out tomorow - New Year’s Eve.

    Mike Smithson



    h1

    Can Blair appeal to the liberal and illiberal at the same time?

    Thursday, December 30th, 2004


    In his attempt to pull off an unprecedented and spectacular third General Election victory Tony Blair is making crime/law & order/ and immigration the centre pieces of Labour’s policy portfolio. These were the main items in the Queen’s Speech last month and they are the centre part of his New Year’s message, just published.

    Before the 1997 Election Blair had the brilliant “Tough on Crime - Tough on the Causes of Crime” rhetoric to underpin his appeal to both the liberal and illiberal. Since then the Home Secretaryships of Straw and Blunkett have put Labour firmly in the authoritarian camp and this will go on. But is it the right strategy? Is he in danger of not pleasing either?

  • Labour continue to trail behind the Tories on these issues which are the one area where the Tories are consistently ahead.
  • Labour needs to hang on to Lib Dem leaning supporters to assure victory and these groups have grown substantialy due to disillusionment over Iraq, tuition fees, and the law and order policies such as ID cards.
  • It reinforces Michael Howard’s record and his “prison works” rhetoric which went down well with the illiberal.
  • The expected voting dynamic of the coming election will be of the Tories flat-lining - but not moving back - but with real volatility between Labour and the Lib Dems. Tony Blair has to be able to shore up switching to the Tories while keeping the liberal faction on board. These objectives might not be possible to reconcile and LD slippage looks to be the most menacing.

      Why not put the focus on Labour’s strengths - the NHS, where the extra investment is starting to show, and the economy where the UK has weathered the recent world down-turn remarkably well?

    Meanwhile the General Election seat spreads have shown one seat movements to both the LDs and Tories. These are from Spreadfair - the spreadbetting exchange. LAB 351.5-353: CON 195-199: LIBD 71 -71.5: SNP 5-6: PC 4-5: UKIP 0.6-1.1

    Users should note that in order to defray some of Politicalbetting’s costs we receive a commission on accounts that are opened through the site.

    Mike Smithson



    h1

    Combine Blunkett & Blair - a possible arbitrage

    Wednesday, December 29th, 2004


    One of the great pleasures of political gambling is when you find situations where whatever happens you end up a winner. With the news in the Sun today that David Blunkett will return to the Cabinet if Tony Blair wins the election then an interesting situation opens up.

    The current best price on Blunkett returning during 2005 is 4/1 which, given the Sun’s status as almost the “official mouthpiece of New Labour” for such things, makes that the best bet there is on Labour winning the General Election. It’s certainly much better value than the 1/6 best price that’s available on Labour winning most seats.

    To cover yourself what about combining the bet with the 7/2 that’s still available on Tony Blair’s tenure as Prime minister ending during 2005?

      So if Blair stays you should win on the Blunkett bet - if he goes you win on the end of tenure bet.

    If just one of these bets comes up you make a profit and the risk of both falling down must be a lot lower than the profit you make at 7/2 and 4/1. There’s also a possibility that you could win on both.

    This is not a true arbitrage because it is just feasible that Blair will still be at Number 10 and Blunkett will not be in the Cabinet. But the Sun story is pretty strong and it’s not often that it gets one of these wrong. There’s also the risk of the election being postponed beyond January 1 2006. But this is worth the punt.

    Get on while this is still available.