(Go: >> BACK << -|- >> HOME <<)

Blenders: in the mix

If you use one at all, which sort of blender do you favour - jug or stick?

Blender
A retro blender.

Len Deighton would not be impressed with me. In his Action Cook Book he devotes a whole chapter to jug blenders, calling them his "Secret Weapon in the Kitchen." He uses his blender for a huge number of things, including making mayonnaise, grinding everything from coffee beans to rice, sieving flour, rescuing lumpy sauces, frothing milk for coffee, as well as liquidising or puréeing solids for soup, mousses and sandwich fillings.

I, on the other hand, am a bit scared of them. In fact, a full blown phobia has crept up on me over the years, due to a high number of accidents associated with them. I've lost count of the number of times I caused eruptions on a volcanic scale and just as hot, either because I had overfilled the thing or failed to remove the stopper when liquidising hot soup.

This was partly my fault – I could never wait for soup to stop steaming before transferring it to the blender. For years I didn't even realise that you were supposed to remove the central cap, assuming that the regularity with which the whole lid flew off, dousing me and my kitchen with scalding hot fluids, was a design fault. It got to the point that I was wincing every time I pressed the on button, in anticipation of the upwards explosion.

The last straw for me was when I accidentally ended up with around 20kg of very large venison livers and tried to use them up by making bulk proportions of paté. The recipe (Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall's from the Meat book) entails soaking breadcrumbs in milk and mixing with uncooked chopped livers and sweated onions before processing in a blender. I ended up with a foul smelling, lumpy paste a blood red colour marbled with various shades of sickly greyish pink. To make matters worse the blender just couldn't cope and after chuntering angrily away for several minutes, it started belching out black smoke and ground to a halt. The clean up operation that day was particularly grim, and that was the end of my relationship with jug blenders (and, for that matter, the remaining venison livers, which were enthusiastically finished off by a neighbour's dog).

Luckily for accident prone people like me, there is an alternative – hand, stick or immersion blender. The advantages of this type of blender are immediately apparent – less washing up, as you can blend at source instead of having to decant, they don't take up counter space, and many of them come with a fair few accessories as standard.

My first was a less sophisticated version of this one which has enough bells and whistles to elevate it almost to food processor territory. I particularly liked the chopping attachments – they seem more efficient than the jug blender at grinding spices and making curry pastes.

However, carelessness when assembling and daily use took its toll, particularly on some of the flimsier plastic parts. My second Braun recently died on me and I looked in vain for a replacement – they have stopped making them for the British market. Instead I opted for a Philips model – it has the same accessories, with an additional serrated blade for chopping ice. It also seems a bit more robust – the motor is more powerful and the plastic feels thicker – the smallest cup hasn't gone cloudy from scratching (a weakness of the Braun), despite being used as a spice grinder several times.

Supersized stick blenders are common in restaurants, though not universally loved. I recall a former boss of mine being obsessive about serving perfectly smooth soups, including Callaloo, which I felt should be much coarser, akin to the texture achievable when using a traditional wooden swizzle stick to blend it. He didn't believe an immersion blender could do as good a job as the jug blender. I am sure it can – if you hold the blender in the same place it creates a whirlpool through which everything eventually passes. I solved his paranoia by passing everything through a fairly coarse chinois to make sure no large chunks of vegetables had escaped the blade, but I wouldn't bother with this at home.

If you use a blender, which type do you favour? Are you a jug devotee or are you as accident prone with them as I am? Do you have any good tips for using either?


Your IP address will be logged

Comments in chronological order

Post a comment
  • This symbol indicates that that person is The Guardian's staffStaff
  • This symbol indicates that that person is a contributorContributor

Showing first 50 comments | Go to all comments | Go to latest comment

  • Verbnoun Verbnoun

    16 Aug 2010, 10:29AM

    Recently bought a cheap jug version, it is our new friend. He's a bit noisy, but gets the job done. I have the opposite impression of stick blenders: I feel like the object being blended is going to go everywhere, where as I feel the jug is more secure. Hmmm, might get it out tonight...

    A friend recently wrote a short obituary to his jug blender, when it packed it in, as his Facebook status update . People certainly get attached to the things...(mine hasn't got a name yet).

  • haddockinthekitchen haddockinthekitchen

    16 Aug 2010, 10:31AM

    Stick blenders are so easy to use, but jug blenders get a smoother result.
    Just my opinion of course.
    Needless to say, I have both. The stick blender is a Bamix, and I have had it for about 15 years - not bad going really.

  • Drspeedy Drspeedy

    16 Aug 2010, 10:35AM

    Totally depends on what I'm trying to achieve - jug for anything which requires smoothness or froth. A stick version, even the modern powerful ones (mine is about 20 years old - one of the very early Brauns) don't turn watercress soup into that smooth velvet that we like. But for 'country-style' soups partial liquidising is great to retain some texture.

    I guess I'm well trained with jug blenders as my only accident was with tomato sauce and a stick blender - phone rang and I lifted the thing still spinning out of the sauce. Given the small amount of material, the thoroughness of the dissemination was amazing and clean up operation took hours.

  • Guerriero Guerriero

    16 Aug 2010, 10:42AM

    The answer is of course that you need both! Try blitzing ice cubes, frozen fruit and a bit of juice with a handheld - at best nothing useful will happen, at worst it'll break, messily. In a blender, the same combo will yield a delicious smoothie with swift washing up. Soups on the other hand with normally be better done with a handheld which allow you to better judge texture and are easier to wash up.

    Sorry not to be helpful!

  • bron99 bron99

    16 Aug 2010, 10:45AM

    Stick blender all the way, as you say you can always sieve for utlra smooth if that's what you need.

    I must admit it's new to me that you should take the central cap out for hot blending... puts a couple of disasters into perspective.

  • chefadomicile chefadomicile

    16 Aug 2010, 10:49AM

    I agree with Guerriero in that you need both if you love to cook, but if I could have only one, the it would have to be the Waring Bar blender. NOTHING works like the Waring, neither as well or for as long. My friends have gone through 3 blenders in the last 3 years as the motor wears out if you try to blend anything other than thin soup. I've found that Giorgio Locatelli's Broad Bean Puree sets the mark for any blender, and a very good recipe it is too! The glass jug to my Waring recently got chipped after 10 years and I was forced to buy a replacement, so my advice would be - if at all possible - to buy a Waring in the States with a metal jug. This seems unavailable in the UK at the moment. WHY? The sticki blender is great for whizzing small amounts in the pan and is useful if it comes with the chopping extras for small amounts of herbs etc. Happy Cooking!

  • tumblestar tumblestar

    16 Aug 2010, 10:54AM

    I would love to use a jug blender more often, however each one seems to last about 2 uses before I end up with a huge seepage out of the bottom. What am I doing wrong that rwecks the seal and is there any hope if it's happened?

  • alocin42 alocin42

    16 Aug 2010, 10:58AM

    Bamix stick blender all the way! I bought a reconditioned one off ebay and it's a proper solid piece of machinery, unlike the cheapo plastic stick blenders I melted several off whizzing up hot soup as a student.

  • Edgeley Edgeley

    16 Aug 2010, 10:59AM

    I don't believe it is possible to use any sort of blender without at least some of the contents ending up on walls and ceilings. Unless of course the contents are the same colour as the wall/ceiling, in which case they will behave themselves.

  • MorganaLeFay MorganaLeFay

    16 Aug 2010, 11:16AM

    I guess that both have their advantages and disadvantages. I am gagging for a jug blender, and hope that one day soon I'll be able to afford one and also get the one I want (must be of a certain max height due to space restrictions, and gotta have a glass jug (NOT plastic!)), but in the meantime I use a stick blender for everything and have quite a bit of spillage. One thing I can say that stick blenders are NOT good to process unpeeled chili peppers, thus Mexican food is currently not big on my menu, un-f**king-fortunately.

  • nilpferd nilpferd

    16 Aug 2010, 11:17AM

    A stick is definitely more convenient but is harder to clean, stuff tends to slop out of the pot, it is harder to achieve a homogeneous mix, and I scour my pots somewhat with it. Also as pointed out, larger chunks in more viscous solutions tend to elude the blades unless you track them down individually.
    It's also a pain pureeing something and then having to lay the dripping stick somewhere without making a mess.

    With a jug, I recommend getting one with an unscrewable base; the glass jug part can go in the dishwasher. Whizzing up half a litre of water after use makes it easier to clean. I've never had explosions; don't overfill them and follow the instructions re the middle cap, etc.

    Plus, as TFD says, there are certain things- smoothies, or anything with ice- which just don't work with a stick.

  • mestizo mestizo

    16 Aug 2010, 11:22AM

    I don't get it - food processors take up hardly and more room than jug blenders, but they actually work. Why does anyone have a jug blender?

    (I had one once, I am haunted by the memories of hours and hours spend pushing bananas down with the special little stick into the orange juice waiting below)

  • besidethesea besidethesea

    16 Aug 2010, 11:24AM

    I had a Krupps mixer and blender set as one of my wedding presents from my parents in 1977. Both are still working although I probably use the mixer more than the blender.

    A couple of years back I did have a fad of making fruit smoothies during the summer months as my breakfast, the blender was in use every single day.

    It's starting to sound a bit ropey now and I think I may have to update it before too long. Still, at 33 years old and still going I'll be sorry to see it finally give up the ghost. I'll give it a decent send-off though!

  • Dragonette Dragonette

    16 Aug 2010, 11:27AM

    Any serious cook will own a food processor(which you should have used for your pate), a jug blender (for cold ingredients) and a stick blender (for hot soups). My stick blender has a couple of other attachments: a whisk and the best small food processor I've ever used, great for making purees of ginger, garlic and chillies and similar ingredients.

  • Sipech Sipech

    16 Aug 2010, 11:29AM

    It's one of those things I think I ought to get, and that it might open up whole new culinery possibilities for me. However, I've got a small kitchen. Also, I'm never sure if the price is justified if all I'm likely to do is make soup a couple of dozen times a year.

    As for grinding spices, always use a pestle & mortar.

  • Benulek Benulek

    16 Aug 2010, 11:31AM

    As for grinding spices, always use a pestle & mortar.

    A coffee grinder is much more efficient. This idea that you should use B.C. technology is an affectation of culinary 'authenticists'.

  • pinkystan pinkystan

    16 Aug 2010, 11:33AM

    Any serious cook will own a food processor(which you should have used for your pate), a jug blender (for cold ingredients) and a stick blender (for hot soups).

    Oh bugger, that means I'm not one. What to do?

  • Benulek Benulek

    16 Aug 2010, 11:36AM

    pinkystan - throw ingredients at the wall and gibber in a very unserious manner. Then get out of the kitchen and leave the cooking to those strange people who think a cook needs more than two knives (a sharp one and one for spreading butter, if you're wondering).

  • Skitten Skitten

    16 Aug 2010, 11:41AM

    The one in the picture is a Waring. I used a Waring for 10 years whilst working in a biochemistry laboratory (for grinding up frozen plant material), so I went and bought one for my kitchen- although they are not cheap, I know they last, and they work really well- 'industrial', in fact. I do love the look of them as well.

  • Orko77 Orko77

    16 Aug 2010, 11:43AM

    Hot soup cracked my Kenwood plastic liquidiser jug, my fancy juicing extension cracked the spindle for the mixer bowl, so now I use an old, preloved and disturbingly brown stained stick. I still have my Kenwood as I have been planning to fix it for about 4 years now.

    PS The stick doesn't work for mashed potato, unless you want potato glue. Must get a masher.

  • Benulek Benulek

    16 Aug 2010, 11:47AM

    A blender stick for mashing potato? Bloody hell, that's like an automated zip fly for uselessness. If a few wallops with a masher aren't sufficient, it's the potatoes you want to change, not the implement you're using.

  • shemarch shemarch

    16 Aug 2010, 11:48AM

    I bought my Osterizer in Canada in 1970 and it is still works perfectly. And the attachments are great too. I make my own peanut butter (no oil added) and make lots of soups. I also have a small Magic Bullet which is great for small quantities and for grinding coffee.

  • CatherinePhipps CatherinePhipps

    16 Aug 2010, 12:06PM

    Contributor Contributor

    @emilou @oceanboy @susansmillie It's not a very exciting story - I'd just put in an order for 1-2 livers with the game supplier at Watton Farmers Market and when I turned up, they'd got a huge box of them. The elderly couple who ran the stall (it was their son, the deer stalker, I'd spoken to), were quite put out and said that I'd have to take the whole box as they were all frozen solid together - they gave me the lot for £15. (Then could be heard muttering angrily when I left, "He never gets anything right, does he?" so I'm guessing the son was in for a bollocking).

    Unfortunately,they were wrong about the livers being frozen together - when I got them home I found they were only partially frozen & came apart quite easily. They took up a whole drawer of the freezer (at the time, I had 2 huge 8 drawer ones for freezing all the garden produce) for ages until I could bring myself to start using them.

    There, said it wasn't an exciting story.

  • ottery ottery

    16 Aug 2010, 12:19PM

    Venison Livers?
    That's like 'Pork Livers'
    Venison is the meat from a deer.
    Pork is Meat from a pig.
    Pig Livers from Pigs.
    Deer Livers come from Deer.

    Use Stick more than Jug blender.

  • alfiegrey alfiegrey

    16 Aug 2010, 12:24PM

    My Magimix solves all of these problems. It's practically bomb proof, whizzes, blends, chops, slices, purees and so on with only one machine to keep in the kitchen. Far better than silly hand held peril.

  • Benulek Benulek

    16 Aug 2010, 12:25PM

    Venison Livers?
    That's like 'Pork Livers'
    Venison is the meat from a deer.
    Pork is Meat from a pig.
    Pig Livers from Pigs.
    Deer Livers come from Deer.

    Where do Superfluous Capital Letters come from?

  • ottery ottery

    16 Aug 2010, 12:38PM

    No you can't say pork livers - how can pork have a liver?
    Surely pigs have livers. Do you think you might have 'bacon livers'?

    Here's Loads Of Superfluous Caps to Keep You Happy Beneluk :-)

  • afinch afinch

    16 Aug 2010, 12:46PM

    Jug blender is ultimately more useful. But I've slowly started to find uses for the food processor/chopper thingy attachment:

    Shortcrust pastry
    Pesto and other pastes (harrissa, curry pastes etc)
    Mayonnaise (works far better than an electric whisk for some reason)

    All these become effortless compared to the 'old' way of making them. But I've never had to chop or slice enough vegetables at once that I can't do it quicker (and cleaner) by hand.

    This mechanical apple slicer remains, however, the best kitchen machine ever.

  • Benulek Benulek

    16 Aug 2010, 12:47PM

    ottery - I think it's reasonable to assume that 'venison livers' would be understood as 'livers belonging to the generic class of meats denoted by the term 'venison''. Same with 'pork livers'. Talking about 'bacon livers' makes no sense as it is a specific cut of pork.

  • pinacolada pinacolada

    16 Aug 2010, 12:47PM

    Symchicken
    16 Aug 2010, 10:20AM
    The question is of course...Will It Blend?

    If it will blend an iphone, then its the blender for me:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qg1ckCkm8YI

    I bought one of these babies and never had any problems, the problem with stick blenders is you have to spend 15 minutes after every use cleaning your walls.

  • c1r2a3i4g5 c1r2a3i4g5

    16 Aug 2010, 12:52PM

    I make a smoothie every day and soups weekly, I go through a stick blender every 12 -18 months before burn out! so I buy a cheapo 20 quid or so and they are generally great value and perfect results! The one time I bought an expensive one it burned out in exactly the same amount of time as the bargain one!

Showing first 50 comments | Go to all comments | Go to latest comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and signed in.

|

Comments

Sorry, commenting is not available at this time. Please try again later.

Recipe Search

Recipe Search

Search by ingredients (separated by comma)

Or search for a recipe by name:

Powered by What Could I Cook.com

Word of Mouth blog – most commented

  1. 1. The bad breakfast club (220)
  2. 2. Eating Britain (71)
  3. 3. How to make the perfect meringue (68)
  4. 4. Budget grub, Yorkshire coast (12)

Word of Mouth blog weekly archives

Aug 2010
M T W T F S S
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31 1 2 3 4 5