(Go: >> BACK << -|- >> HOME <<)

Depression – the illness that's still taboo

On paper, things looked good for Mark Rice-Oxley: wife, children, fulfilling job. But then, at his 40th birthday party, his whole world crumbled as he succumbed to depression

Mark Rice-Oxley
Mark Rice-Oxley: 'I got stronger. I learned how to let time pass without trying to fill it.' Photograph: Martin Godwin for the Guardian

I can't say exactly when it started. Maybe the day in July last year when a headache in the shape of a question mark curled itself around my right eye and made itself at home. Or a month later, when a liquid fatigue poured into my legs and set. The autumn perhaps, when short, surreal episodes would come and go, like I was seeing the world through the bottom of a highball glass.

But the moment when I really knew something was wrong was the night of my 40th birthday party in October. We were motoring up the Thames with a boatful of my closest friends all dressed in 1969 fancy dress and Woodstock wigs. I felt overwhelmed. From under my Jimi Hendrix hair I whispered to my mother, "Stay close." I gripped her hand as if it were the first day at school. I couldn't look anyone in the face for more than three seconds without a tide of screaming panic rising up. I tried to circulate but needed to sit. When I sat, I needed to stand. I tried eating, then threw my dinner in the bin. At last midnight came and we all went home. That night, for the first of many dark nights, I lay awake, small and frightened, and utterly unable to keep still through the dreadful hours.

It got worse. For two weeks I felt neither ill nor well. Then, during a weekend at my parents' home – the house I was born in, the place I still love – I disintegrated. It was the weekend the clocks went back, and as we arrived I rippled with a sense of unease. I couldn't watch television or read. I started cups of tea but couldn't finish them, sat down to dinner but couldn't eat. The first night I roamed around, twitchy and unable to settle, heart hammering in my throat, ears full of white noise, a buzz in my stomach. At 5am, I couldn't take any more. I knocked on my parents' door and soon found myself wedged between them in bed, for the first time since I was born. The next night was worse. I was rocking back and forward, ranging, pacing, terrifying everyone. When I blurted out something about how it was all finished for me, my dad jumped into the car to find an out-of-hours NHS dispensary. "At least we're making the most of the extra hour," he said.

They used to call it a nervous breakdown. Now it's depression. Neither term is helpful. The former doesn't come close to expressing the long list of symptoms that apply (insomnia, anxiety, dismal mood, panic, thoughts of suicide, loss of energy/weight/joy/libido/love). The latter is, if anything, worse, conjuring up misleading images of people staring through windows at drizzle. But depressive illness isn't like that Monday-morning feeling, or getting back from holiday to find the cold water tank has burst. It's a medical fact, like breaking an arm, only the broken bit is in the chemical circuitry of the brain. It's delicate stuff in there. It takes a long time to fix. Usually, I am told, you get better.

If there was one consolation it was that I was not alone. My decline from unremarkable working dad of three to stranded depressive sitting on the floor doing simple jigsaws certainly felt unique. In fact, it's universal. The chances of the average adult getting it are perhaps higher than they have ever been.

According to Graham Thornicroft, a professor of community psychiatry at the Institute of Psychiatrists, between 20% and 25% of adults will have an episode of mental illness in any given year. Over a lifetime, the risk rises to around 40%. In Britain, antidepressant prescriptions have doubled in the last decade. The World Health Organisation warns that by 2030 depression will be second only to HIV/Aids in the toll it exacts on society.

"Life has become more stressful and there is more alienation than there used to be. People who meet disadvantage meet it very much alone," says Tim Cantopher, a psychiatrist and author of Depressive Illness: Curse of the Strong

Who's most at risk? "Women and poor people," says Thornicroft. "General rates of depression among women are up to twice as high as among men. And in lowest socio-economic groups it is up to twice as much as in higher groups."

I fit neither category, so why me? Depression is often triggered by sudden life events such as bereavement, loss of job or change of house. But again, none of these apply. Far more common however is a stress-induced condition that may build over a number of years.

"If you try to do the undoable, you're going to get this," Cantopher says. "Stress doesn't make you ill. You do – by trying to do the undoable."

And, if I'm honest, I have been trying to do the undoable for years. I have realised I am essentially an idle soul inhabiting a very busy person's life. Years of late-night shifts and early mornings with small children asking tricky questions such as, "Daddy, if you had to break one of your legs, which one would you break?" I was a "portfolio parent", part-time work, part-time homedad, part-time freelancer. On paper, it looked marvellous. In reality, it made for long years of chaotic breakfasts, a messy school run, some exercise, a dash into London, 10 hours on a pinball newsdesk, back to release my wife for a school governors' meeting or a conference call or to move the house slightly to the left. Late for everything.

I understand that this is the lot that many working women have had to bear for decades. I find it unsurprising that so many are succumbing to depressive illness. But since I "came out", I found a startling number of do-it-all fathers who are suffering too.

Mark Rice-Oxley 40th birthday Mark Rice-Oxley in his Hendrix gear at his 40th birthday party – the point when his depression took hold.

And yet not many of us find it easy to be forthcoming about our illness. Thornicroft's real killer stat is this: that 75% of us know someone with mental illness. But we may not know they are mentally ill. Because, of course, mental illness is a taboo. And few people talk about it or let on – unless they are so ill that they can't help it.

Sue Baker, director of the Time to Change programme set up to change negative attitudes towards mental illness, says nine out of 10 people with mental illness say they have experienced stigma and discrimination. "Yet, paradoxically, 'coming out' can be the best thing for someone with a mental illness. It can have a powerful influence," says Baker. "If you don't disclose, then people who might help you aren't going to be able to."

I tried to be honest and, in return, people did well at asking all the right questions. How has it been? What's it like? Why did it happen to you? In the interests of brevity, I usually just said "Pretty tough" or "I'm on the mend" or "not out of the woods yet". What I really wanted to say is: there were days when I just sat on the bed and stared at the wall and wondered if I was losing my mind, when even trying to do a child's jigsaw puzzle would wear me out. Days – long joined-up hours when I thought I would never work, write, parent, play or love again. Days when I agonised at the enormous burden my wife was under; when I resented the impact on my children, two of whom seemed to develop mild sympathetic symptoms; when I wondered how much further there was to the bottom. But the days weren't the problem. Nights were worse. Sleeplessness became both symptom and cause of the illness, a wicked loop of empty hours and catastrophic thoughts. By 4am I'd be desperate for dawn. But morning brought no relief, just more empty hours, with another threatening night thereafter.

Christmas was the lowest ebb. All that snow, all the lovely children with faces shiny like apples. I couldn't be near them, but couldn't be alone. I trailed around the house after my poor wife like a small dog with internal bleeding. I slept eight hours in four nights. On 23 December, I went for an emergency meeting with my psychiatrist who shook his head and said, "I'm sorry it's turned out this way." Afterwards, in the thickening twilight and with the first vapours of sedation gathering, I felt my wretchedness in the joy of others: the shoppers and their gift bags; the lovers giggling; the young man on the tube engrossed in a book. I wish I was him, I thought. I wish I was engrossed in a book on the tube.

How do you get better? Like wars and love affairs, depression is a thing that is easy to get started but difficult to bring to a close. Somehow, time passed. Days dragged by so slow, but weeks seemed to mount up quickly. The lost time began to unsettle me, so I found different units to measure the duration of my illness: in haircuts, porridge boxes, Countdown octochamps. Any kind of stress was insupportable. But also any kind of excitement. Television could overwhelm me. I couldn't watch sport, felt seasick at the motion and envious of the energy of the participants. Small social events helped, but only for about half an hour. Thereafter diminishing returns set in, and they diminished pretty rapidly: if you overexert in any way, very bad days follow. I spent hours and hours with a deck of cards, and camomile tea, and got pretty bored of both.

The four things that really helped: meditation, love, time and therapy. I discovered the first through a colleague who sent me some CDs. At first, meditation feels hard and slightly odd. In time, it's a valuable technique. Love – in a child's Halloween face, or a friend's casual invitation to lunch, boosted morale. Time worked away on the broken bits. Therapy taught me that I'm not who I think I am, that some of my reflexes and instincts are unhealthy.

But it wasn't a smooth ride. Some days, exercise would help. Some days, it was too much and I'd suffer for two or three days. Some days, odd jobs felt wholesome, sometimes they felt depleting. Some days, just making dinner would be too much. Other days, I would feel like doing nothing, but know that doing nothing was the worst thing I could do. Some days, most painfully of all, being with the children was just too much. At other times, just to sit and watch them climb or paint was a blessed relief. I could still parent, after all.

"Be a scientist, not a manager," says Cantopher. "Look at the evidence that your body gives you. If you are overdoing it, your body will tell you. You've got to pace it in the early stages. To begin with, do a little – leave tasks half done, don't try to complete things at the beginning. Be kind and gentle to yourself. Once you are better, then it's about recognising that if you keep putting 18 amps through a 13 amp fuse, it will keep blowing."

Spring helped. I got stronger. I finished reading a novel for the first time since September. I put on all the weight I'd lost and more. I planted potatoes, cooked, sifted compost, borrowed a neighbour's bike. I kept a nerdy graph of how I was feeling, and took comfort in a general upward trend behind the violent peaks and troughs. Good friends brought lunch and we walked and talked. The office sent a box set of The Wire. Pretty soon I was up to watching it. I began to notice things more, things I had taken for granted for years – beauty, seasons, people. I bought birthday presents on time. I rediscovered gentle ways to spend the time – chess, libraries, yoga. I learned how to let time pass without trying to fill it.

It wasn't straightforward. I relapsed six weeks after going back to work and needed another month to build up from the bottom again. Even now, a year on from that first, dark question mark, I still feel the sharp edge of something. But, happily, it does little more than prod me, remind me that I need to tread carefully.

I wouldn't wish this illness on my worst enemy; it's the most terrifying thing that has ever happened to me. But, in a strange way, I am glad of the lessons it taught me. "A lot of patients are grateful," says Cantopher. "They say that without the illness they wouldn't have been able to make the changes they made to become happy."

It has been strange writing this story. Almost like I am writing about another person. A friend died the other day at 44. My story seems trivial by comparison. But it is a story I really wanted to tell because it is a story I wanted to read 12 months ago, when I was desperate for reassurance. Yes, it's tough, yes, it'll turn your life upside down. But it does get better. You do recover. I've nearly made it. You can make it too.


Your IP address will be logged

Comments in chronological order

Post a comment
  • This symbol indicates that that person is The Guardian's staffStaff
  • This symbol indicates that that person is a contributorContributor

Showing first 50 comments | Go to all comments | Go to latest comment

  • Gabbyco Gabbyco

    2 Aug 2010, 9:41AM

    I feel sympathy for those with Depression but I don't understand why someone in this article would suffer depression given his personal life.

    Obviously he has organic depression from within.

    Try suffering as a post op TS, the depression is relentless. I may not lie awake at night but having to be treated as a second class citizen in Britain really is depressing. In my case, nothing will alleviate that, pills make you fat and make you worse and are not the answer and therapy doesn't work either. Try excercise it keeps me sane.

    Everyone's circumstances are unique but I do feel sorry for the people with bipolar as opposed to Dhysmithic type of depression which most transgendered people have at one point or another. I have most probably spelt it wrong.

    Life is a bitch and you have to get on with it. That's just my personal point of view as I am not one to fee sorry for myself so may be I am not depressed at all.

  • Sutch Sutch

    2 Aug 2010, 9:44AM

    Depression is caused by poverty or by the death of a loved one. It can also be hereditary.
    Winston Churchill suffered from depression. He called it "the black dog on my shoulder".
    I am very surprised to hear that it is taboo. Who decides that?

  • dourscot dourscot

    2 Aug 2010, 9:44AM

    Not convinced by those rather alarmist stats on depression rates. More anti-depressants are handed out because doctors want an easy life. It doesn't mean there are more people who need them. Forty percent of adults with depression at some stage and 25 percent in any one year? That seems extremely speculative.

  • Kat86 Kat86

    2 Aug 2010, 9:45AM

    Thank you for sharing this. A dear friend of mine has been suffering from depression for some years, and it's useful to know what it might feel like from her perspective. I hope that both you and she are able to find ways to cope and will be able to enjoy life again.

  • LibertarianLou LibertarianLou

    2 Aug 2010, 9:46AM

    @Mark Rice-Oxley

    You're a brave man and I wish you all the best.

    @Gabbyco

    Depression isn't anything to do with feeling sorry for yourself. I know sufferers who don't feel sorry for themselves at all, and in fact feel (on top of everything else) terrible guilt for experiencing the depression they do, given their relatively speaking decent life circumstances. If anything, some of them probably would feel a bit better if they gave themselves a break once in a while. Many sufferers are much, much too hard on themselves.

    I sympathise with much of your post though and also wish you the best of luck for the future.

  • jacky21130 jacky21130

    2 Aug 2010, 9:47AM

    This article made me smile and cry all in the space of reading it. My mum suffers bad depression and I never understood how she felt until the day it became a part of my life at the age of 29. I just felt compelled to write and say thank you for sharing your experiences. Like you say, you wouldn't wish it on anyone and I find the most difficult thing is getting people to understand just how it feels when you have never experienced it. Thank you again and best wishes in keeping well.

  • lecorsaire lecorsaire

    2 Aug 2010, 9:53AM

    This comment has been removed by a moderator. Replies may also be deleted.
  • giahosinn giahosinn

    2 Aug 2010, 9:55AM

    Yes I know the story. There is little help for people, I think especially for the working class etc. The worst thing is when people HAVE to go to work, everyone is depending on them. This is true for both sexes and although depression is higher for women the suicides rates in general are higher for men.

    One of the problems can be GPs do not really recognise depression much, except with the "pull yourself together, you malingerer" approach, also looking deeper into the root causes with the Freudian aspect, this is not included much in the NHS facility even for those who are lucky enough to get help.

    I think people need a holiday from life sometimes and that includes from their children, although they can feel guilty about this it's necessary.

    Good article. More should be done to explore the effects of depression on the classes that, as the article says, suffer the most from it. How does the help facilities that have kicked in for our writer work for those who are most vulnerable to it.i.e. I note his office was kind enough to send a box set of The Wire round to some jobs would offer them the sack.

  • Gelion Gelion

    2 Aug 2010, 9:55AM

    A close friend of my g/f and I suffered from acute Depression and had awful times; black unremitting despair, was unable to go out in public, lost his job, broke up with his girl friend.

    He had counselling, psychotherapy and drugs. Nothing worked. We thought he would be sectioned.

    He then was taken to see a hypnotherapist and within a few months he had his illness under control.

    A year later he describes it as being able to control his bleak episodes and mostly now he does not have them.

    I strongly urge anyone suffering from depression to seek a hypnotherapist trained in treating this awful disease of the mind.

  • jimfred jimfred

    2 Aug 2010, 9:56AM

    Modern life,with the goals and targets that we all have been trained to strive for,can be the bannana skin that slips you into depression.
    Keeping busy is good.
    I could not get out of bed,suffering with anxiety and depression.
    I was totally cynical about medication or help.
    I was dragged off to my G.P.He was a diamond.Put me on Citalaprom,felt worse for a while,then got better,got my life back,off the meds.
    I know there are pitfalls,recomending medication that worked for me,(that is the job of the professionals),and there are no 'magic pills',but taking the tablets,saved my life.

    Got to go,people to see,places to go.........................

  • UnAnneeSansPizza UnAnneeSansPizza

    2 Aug 2010, 10:00AM

    I went through a spell of depression last year so awful that, on one occasion, it took me two and three quarter hours to summon up the energy to walk the ten metres from my bed to the toilet. Getting to sleep at night required a Herculean feat of concentration while my mind was blitzed with random, unrelated images, and over Christmas week I managed five hours of sleep in four nights. On December 23rd I had people asking me if they could ponce some of the drugs I was on, when in reality it was just the lack of sleep.

    Substantial therapy and modification of lifestyle has led to, touch wood, eight months without a serious depressive episode. I hope to God I never have to spend 165 minutes of my life working up the will to have a piss, again.

  • djmikeyc djmikeyc

    2 Aug 2010, 10:02AM

    This comment has been removed by a moderator. Replies may also be deleted.
  • surprisedzoe surprisedzoe

    2 Aug 2010, 10:02AM

    Thank you for writing this.

    It is so hard to explain the grip of depressive anxiety and how it makes everything you do difficult.

    I have spent the first two years of my daughter's life as a functioning single parent who accessorises her look with a great big belt with an anxious knot as a belt buckle. Quite often the belt is too tight and the buckle digs in and I can barely breathe.

    Yet if someone asks me what I am scared of I couldn't possibly say, except maybe 'everything'.

    It is good that you can write this, better that you found the love and support to help you through what is something that is so hard to explain.

    Carry on living, slowly, happily, socially, quietly... whatever suits your mood.

  • Epanastis25Martiou Epanastis25Martiou

    2 Aug 2010, 10:08AM

    Thanks for the wonderful article.

    I'd be keen, however, to know the role that medication like Prozac, Seroxat etc have in propogating / prolonging the symptoms.

    There seems to be a ready and setady suipply of "Ludes" to get you going but this seems to be alleviating the symptoms and not the cause.

    The words yoga, meditation and other holistic stuff seems to help - why is this not incorporated more into mainstream thinking? (I ask at the risk of pissing off Goldacre and other non-believers)

  • nomeatpete nomeatpete

    2 Aug 2010, 10:09AM

    Thanks for your honesty and openess in writing this article.
    I work with people who have minor mentel illness( as opposed to severe and enduring like psychosis) which Depression comes under. Most of our clients have isolated themselves, which either compounds or creates their depression. It sounds like you have a good supportive group of people around you - , family friends and work etc.
    Our project has been running for 9 yrs and in the last 2yrs more and more men have been referred.
    I am convinced that there are many men out there who won't admitt they have depression and self medicate with alcohol or street drugs. Thats why the figures for men are so low .
    -'Who's most at risk? "Women and poor people," says Thornicroft. "General rates of depression among women are up to twice as high as among men. And in lowest socio-economic groups it is up to twice as much as in higher groups'
    Thanks again for giving hope to all those who go thru this aweful debilitating illness.

  • TaylorL TaylorL

    2 Aug 2010, 10:09AM

    Is depression really still taboo - as your headline says? I don't think it is. At least half of the (middle-class) women I know talk openly about it. And we've had countless personal stories about it in recent years.

    However, i do agree with a previous poster - it's such a shame that the media focuses solely on white, middle-class men and women suffering from depression. Does anyone care about the chronic levels of depression among those living in poverty?

    This, I think, has contributed to a bit of the lack of sympathy in some quarters towards people writing about depression.

    Some experts believe some forms of depression are caused by having unrealistic expectations and also by the fact that we live in a far more isolated, competitive, individualistic society.

    Figures suggest that depression will be the single biggest health problem after heart disease by 2020. I'm afraid I think we have reached a point where the human condition has been medicalised.

    Years ago, people thought - life is suffering. Nowadays, people think they should be happy all the time. I actually think periods of extreme sadness and meaninglessness are a normal part of life.

    I write as someone who was previously diagnosed as having depression. It was hell at the time. But looking back, I think it was a normal passage to adulthood....a bit like adolescence all over again.

  • Gabbyco Gabbyco

    2 Aug 2010, 10:11AM

    @LibertarianLou.

    Yes I suppose some people are like that. Depression is different for different people. I don't regard myself as depressed per se and neither would my GP but it is true that Depression isn't always related to life circumstances or chances the wealthy get depressed too.

    I don't think it is a taboo illness not these days not like it was. Thanks for your best wishes though.

    Regards

  • Monchberter Monchberter

    2 Aug 2010, 10:11AM

    an idle soul inhabiting a very busy person's life

    A sentiment I completely agree with. This is probably one of the reasons that I have had to deal with similar issues myself recently.

    Beating it is a very individual thing, and advice can only take you so far, so i'm not going to say what worked for me. But a change of job, finding love and redefining my priorities all helped.

    All the best.

  • unicorn7 unicorn7

    2 Aug 2010, 10:13AM

    Thanks for the article, it was very moving.

    I too suffer with depression, and have done since I was 18. It's been something that has affected a lot of members of my family, and it can be absolutely terrible. Seeing as it is in fact so common, it's rubbish that there is still such a taboo about it. If people spoke about it more, people who suffered wouldn't feel so isolated or crazy.

    For me, it has been a recurrent illness that seems to come once a year and in the winter, particularly. This has happened for 10 years, and now I dread the winter. I'm a totally different person when I'm depressed, and I still put so much effort into trying to hide the fact that I am depressed at work.

    I work in a creative profession, and when I feel depressed, I find it difficult to be creative. This is a problem I'm trying to learn to deal with, as I love my job.

    "I learned how to let time pass without trying to fill it."

    This quote rang very true, and I think one thing that people who haven't suffered with depression don't understand is it's not feeling sad that is the worst thing, it's the constant preoccupation with how to fill your time, and a general uneasiness in every situation.

    I hope you remain strong and happy, and keep fighting the black dog.

  • Gabbyco Gabbyco

    2 Aug 2010, 10:14AM

    I would say one thing though, Depression is far more common amongst women and women are more likely to be sectioned than men because women are more likely to seek help men don't.

    Depression isn't a taboo illness as it is very common and out of all so called mental illnesses the most taboo I would regard is either Schzioprenia or Personality Disorder, the former scares people the latter isn't very treatable in some cases.

    I do agree with the posting above that some depressed people use alcohol or drugs to quell their illness but it doesn't stop there some people might use gambling and or sex or food too. People likely to do the latter are more manic depressive than depressive in terms of being up and being down at times.

  • Chriswr Chriswr

    2 Aug 2010, 10:15AM

    @lecorsaire

    but of course it's not a poor woman whose viewpoint we are allowed to hear: it's yet another rich, successful, straight, white man, telling us how hard it can be to be a rich, successful, straight, white man. Our hearts bleed.

    Maybe we can get obsessive class hatred classified as a mental illness too?

  • Shewhowillnotbenamed Shewhowillnotbenamed

    2 Aug 2010, 10:15AM

    Thanks so much for writing this ! You articulated it so well

    Something very similar happened to me eight years ago. I had almost all the symptoms you describe ! It was awful and for so long I didn't even know what was wrong with me. (That sounds, silly, I know !). For so long I couldn't even think straight about how I was feeling. But then I just went to my G.P. one day and just poured my heart out. I managed to get up enough energy to get myself to the south of France for a month to do a course in French. It went well so I stayed a month longer than I had intended and did some volunteer work. It was physically exhausting but good for me I think. Things slowly somehow got better. France was sunny and warm and new and to this day I think the change set me on the road to recovery.

    It took me about a year to recover fully but I got there. I still slip from time to time. In fact, yesterday and the day before were not so good. This morning is not so bad. Plus, your piece has just given me a bit of a boost.

    Thanks.

  • Doveman Doveman

    2 Aug 2010, 10:19AM

    I wouldn't describe what the author was suffering from as depression. It certainly sounds far more like a nervous breakdown, or you could say depression with general anxiety disorder (and maybe a few more things).

    I've suffered from depression since I was a teenager, so a long time. Not constantly of course, but easily triggered by certain situations that highlight what I see as my inadequacies. It tends to make me weepy, oversensitive, exhausted and can't be bothered and I certainly don't have any trouble sleeping (quite the opposite). That's what I consider depression to be like.

    I've been on a lot of SSRIs, all of which only caused extreme fatigue (I've never had that much energy anyway) and other side-effects. None made me feel happy.

    I've also been on tricyclics, which had much fewer side-effects although I'm not sure they made that much difference to the depression. Unfortunately, they did have the side-effect of causing dry mouth and eyes, which often caused me to wake up with a sore watering eye that prevented me leaving the house all day!

    I was recently diagnosed with a Vitamin B12 deficiency and started taking sublinguals to supplement the 3-monthly injections from my GP. At some point, I woke up feeling more happy than I can remember being since I was about 6, which lasted a few hours. Unfortunately I haven't been able to recreate that feeling, but it certainly suggests to me that my body needs large amounts of vitamins and minerals to produce enough serotonin to feel normal, and medication isn't going to provide those.

    "Who's most at risk? "Women and poor people," says Thornicroft. "General rates of depression among women are up to twice as high as among men. And in lowest socio-economic groups it is up to twice as much as in higher groups.""

    I would imagine a lot of single and lonely men are at risk too, regardless of how rich or poor they are, as they won't have the support of a partner or friends to help them, so to say that "You do recover" when many people don't (and some kill themselves) is a bit arrogant, particularly coming from a wealthy guy with a loving family.

  • popsikov popsikov

    2 Aug 2010, 10:21AM

    This is a good start in the Guardian for personal stories of suffering depression. Can we have the next one soon please and many more. I'd like one by a poor black woman whose husband has left her with the misbehaving children and who cleans for an income. Followed by the old lady who lives at the top of some high rise flats where the lift keeps breaking down. And one by a teenager who keeps self-harming. And one by the parent whose child has died in an accident at the age of 18. Etc etc.... I'm not trying to diminish Mr Rice-Oxley's suffering, but I wish the Guardian would publish articles by people who never read the Guardian, people who write poorly, and people in differing socio-economic classes. Everyone suffers - does the Guardian only want contributors who suffer articulately?

  • bananasthemonkey bananasthemonkey

    2 Aug 2010, 10:22AM

    When it comes to depression, I sometimes think there are two types of people: those who have experienced or had somebody close to them experience it and those who have not. It is difficult for those who have had no contact with this illness to understand the darkness it brings with it and the depth of its impact on sufferers and their loved ones. The 'what are you worrying about your life is perfect' brigade just don't get it.

    Incidentally, and personally speaking, I am a big fan of the drugs. They saved my marriage and gave us a normal life back. They continue to do so whenever the black dog rears its ugly head again.

  • stitchus stitchus

    2 Aug 2010, 10:23AM

    I found this to be a sensitive and articulate account of the experience of depression. Thank you for sharing this Mark.

    There is still much ignorance and misunderstanding about depression, some of which is evident in a number of the comments so far. Depression is not a disease, and promoting this myth disempowers those affected - and their loved ones - with a sense of helplessness that they can do little about this condition that has simply 'happened' for no apparent reason.

    In all but a tiny minority of cases where there is an inherent physiological imbalance, depression is the consequence of an unresolved emotional trauma. Our emotions are designed to help us process life's experiences. None should be labelled 'good' or 'bad' - all serve a key purpose in our fucntioning. Grief, for example, helps us resolve or come to terms with loss - if we allow ourselves to experience the grief.

    When we deny an emotion or block its progress we store it up inside and it becomes 'depressed'. The energy of it then weighs us down and can build over time - causing the kind of symptoms that Mark describes so eloquently.

    My own depression stemmed from an experience of childhood bullying combined with a lack of emotional support. Although it was an understandable reaction at the time I cut off from how the bullying made me feel. At 31 I haven't had a significant experience of depression in 10 years, but I am still working with the support of therapy to process the feelings I have about being bullied that remain 'depressed' within me.

    I would like to encourage more sufferers to share the stories behind their depression. These can help address some damaging myths and support others to understand that depression is not so much a mystery but a very human predicament.

  • ursuppe ursuppe

    2 Aug 2010, 10:23AM

    lecorsaire
    it's yet another rich, successful, straight, white man, telling us how hard it can be to be a rich, successful, straight, white man. Our hearts bleed.

    I'm sorry that you read it that way. I read it as someone who has been through a serious illness telling us what it was like.

    Would you have posted the same comment had he been writing about a debilitating, usually recurring and often fatal physical disease? MS, for instance? Or maybe nothing that a rich, successful, straight, white man goes through can evoke a humanitarian response.

    You talk about damaging myths- the one that says that the only meaningful suffering happens to poor and oppressed minorities is worse. If you can't drag up the smallest amount of empathy for someone in pain just because of his class, gender, race or sexuality, how do you expect him to do the same for you?

  • quantock quantock

    2 Aug 2010, 10:24AM

    Yep that's exactly what it's like. Been there. Doing the undoable for years til the fuse blows. And there is still stigma. Some allegedly intelligent people still treat me warily - but it's about their own fears re themselves. Serious clinical depression takes a long time to creep up on you, then the great unravelling and the long climb to getting well again. The big story though is NHS 'treatment'. Mine was absolutely appaling, it's a miracle I didn't top myself.

  • glory1961 glory1961

    2 Aug 2010, 10:26AM

    Lucky man, he appears to have got over a dreadful 'episode'.
    Can you imagine what its like to have had your first depression at 18, and still troubled at 64, but managed by medication for the last 20 years.

  • Arianwen Arianwen

    2 Aug 2010, 10:26AM

    An achingly well-written article, and just so recognisable. The days that take weeks, the weeks that disappear. For instance, I remember nothing about 2007. I know that a year passed, and things must have happened, but it is simply impenetrable.

    I'm poor and female, so unfortunately, I'm likely to suffer from depression for quite some time. My partner also has depression, and neither of us can get up to make breakfast quite yet. Oh well. At least we have each other.

  • RockaBella RockaBella

    2 Aug 2010, 10:26AM

    Reading through the comments section its funny to see how many people think they understand it and then clearly make visible that they didn't.

    The problem really is that depression is, for many people, a chronic illness that can reoccur at any time in your life, regardless of your circumstances and that is part of the problem - feeling guilty about the fact that you feel the way you are since on the surface level you have absolutely no reason to feel this way.
    I am about to become 26 years in a few weeks and I have been suffering from Depression since the age of 13 in three clearly defineable spells and many smaller episodes and each one was completely different. First long period I was, at least in my thoughts, suicidal, second I wasn't and third I spent a lot of time biting myself so hard in the skin on my fingers that it left marks for a couple days or digging my fingernails in my flesh just so I wouldn't have to feel that nauseous hollowness in the pit of my stomach. Not a pleasent feeling, I can assure you.

    And while it's not taboo to talk about it as such, it is still problematic. Try tell your Uni Professor that you couldn't hand in your assignment because you couldn't even bring yourself to get out of bed until 5 in the afternoon without having to fear the loss of his esteem in your ability to work academically...

    It's not something that you can "snap out of" or that can be cured by "thinking about the poor kids in Africa" (all statements people made when I told them about it... and they were good friends, not some strangers) but a process over time. I have to this date not touched an antidepressant but thankfully I have been feeling really well in the last year, better than I have ever felt before - even though I know its more likely a ceasefire rather than the end of the war.

  • jonana jonana

    2 Aug 2010, 10:27AM

    Thank you for this. A beautiful, if difficult, read.

    I asked my mum recently what our family illnesses are. Depression, she said, going back generations on her side; suicides, breakdowns, black dogs. I'm even related to a Victorian lady who attempted suicide in a notable way; she flung herself off a bridge, but her stiff whalebone skirt caught the air and broke her fall, allowing her to survive.

    So many of my friends and family have had depressive episodes. Phew, I thought, I've escaped. Turns out I haven't. Ah well.

  • Pyromancer Pyromancer

    2 Aug 2010, 10:27AM

    While the ubiquity of the moniker 'depression' is probably helping to diminish the taboo of the illness, it is probably also - in being too readily banded about - causing a lack of sympathy from those who quickly 'recover' from their weekend of feeling unsure of who they are / anxiety about the future.

    Like people who call their winter cold 'flu', people who self diagnose depression based on a few of its symptoms do much to undermine the seriousness of the illness. It seems that everybody who has experienced, either first hand or vicariously, the harrowing symptoms of depression, takes umbrage with the term - and rightly so when it comes to be perceived as 'staring at drizzle through windows'.

    There's a difficult Catch 22 here, though. Renaming 'depression' something along the lines of 'Personality Infraction Disorder' or 'Acute Frontal Lobe Imbalance' might serve to highlight the severity of the issue, but would probably also increase both the shame often felt by sufferers and the stigma surrounding the condition.

  • drsocialpolicy drsocialpolicy

    2 Aug 2010, 10:33AM

    A very good article that was touching and honest, many thanks.

    Depression is a difficult condition for the individual experiencing, their family and friends to understand and for wider society to fully comprehend. It is one the major issues facing the public health of adults in the UK and much of the developed world and we need to understand its causes and treatments much better than we currently do.

    While we have made progress, there is still a long way to go in terms of breaking down the stigma associated with mental health issues. The solutions can vary but the benefits of cognitive behavioural therapy - talking therapies - are considerable and probably preferable to drug treatment in many cases.

    As well as providing appropriate support for people experiencing depression, we need to develop approaches to improve the mental health and wellbeing of the population as a whole. Why? Although we are considerably wealthier than we were a generation ago, we are not happier and the burdens are felt most keenly by women and poor people. This will not always be easy but we ignore poor mental health at our peril and need to take measures to improve our mental health and wellbeing over our life course.

  • hippetyhop hippetyhop

    2 Aug 2010, 10:34AM

    Excellent article, thanks for writing it. For me medication was a magic wand that loosened the huge knot of anxiety and misery. I'm full of admiration for someone who can soldier through to the other side without that help.

    @Sutch - There is quite a taboo around mental illness - I found many people were embarrassed if I spoke about being depressed, as if I'd told them I had genital warts or something. Weirdly, the most unsympathetic was another sufferer: "Call that depressed? I cried for six weeks straight, now THAT'S depressed!"

  • slowreader slowreader

    2 Aug 2010, 10:35AM

    Thanks for this article, I'll bookmark it and link to it whenever some idiot on an Internet forum dismisses depression as 'just having a bad day' or 'feeling a bit down'.

    Please ignore lecorsaire's spiteful comment, which reminded me of a Socialist Worker film review: 'not a bad film, but there was no mention of the working class'.

  • wonover wonover

    2 Aug 2010, 10:45AM

    I have a partner who is suffering from mental health issues. He 'came out' a year ago after keeping it to himself for many years. I hate the stigma associated with mental health/illness. Just because you can't see it, it doesn't mean it isn't there.

    I would like to see an article from the 'other persons' point of view as, although the person suffering from MI has it tough, often their partner/husband/wife etc. is left to deal with the fall-out which can often cause a relationship to come to an end as the pressure is just too much.

    Well done for being so brave. I will take your article home for my partner to read and hopefully realise that there is light at the end of the tunnel, albeit a blooming long one!

  • shack1 shack1

    2 Aug 2010, 10:45AM

    Thanks Mark, for a genuinely affecting article. (I did buy the paper, don't fret!)

    Am pretty-much the same age as you/similar circumstances, and your story resonated. Better to read the thoughts of someone who suffers, rather than a doctor who thinks he's got the cure-all pills.

    I've tried them: the drugs don't work, they just make it worse, IMHO.

    Interesting comments, though.

    lecorsaire - I don't think this 'illness' (if that what it is) is a class / income / race issue. in 2010, nearly EVERYONE seems to be 'working class', ultimately? I understand your ire, though.

    giahosinn - interesting what you say about GPs. Went to mine a few months back and he recommended/insisted on some SSRIs. While he was blathering on about the benefits of SSRIs, all I noticed was his desk stationery (stapler/notepad), branded by his prefered meds company logo. I felt like I was a patsy for NHS business. He has otherwise been a decent GP.

    Best wishes to all.

  • Keavers Keavers

    2 Aug 2010, 10:46AM

    Firstly, well done on and excellent thoughful, and brave article. It is so crucial that mental illness is openly discussed, at least for us sufferers, to read that others have the same bleak feelings as yourself on one of the greatest comforts.

    I've have had two extreme episodes of depression, both lasting a couple of months. For what its worth I truly believe the root cause of depressive illnesses is indeed stress. Depression is often linked to family bereavement, abrupt change of lifestlyle or any other radically life altering event, but I think the common denominator in all of these scenarios is stress. The constraint strain modern life exacts on one's mind can have a devasting cumulative effect. The said effect can also be very stealthy, hence the sudden unprecendented plunge into depression so many sufferers report.

    I really applaud your honesty and thoroughness when telling your story, these articles and discourses really have a positive effect, good luck on your ongoing journey, you will be in my thoughts!

  • WellArdSponge WellArdSponge

    2 Aug 2010, 10:51AM

    "

    Life has become more stressful and there is more alienation than there used to be

    " - Tim Cantopher.

    It seems to me that the belief that life has become more stressful rather belittles the experiences that our ancestors (including recent ones) underwent.

    Ignoring the two most recent world wars, the days when unemployment brought the work house or starvation, are not so very distant – and as to alienation – why is that assumed to be a new thing when, if anything, the rate of social change is slowing and mobility (in terms of time spent travelling) is lessening?

    Have you looked at the admission rates of 'lunatic asylums'? - they make for interesting reading.

  • stanbowles stanbowles

    2 Aug 2010, 10:51AM

    This comment has been removed by a moderator. Replies may also be deleted.
  • lovejoype9 lovejoype9

    2 Aug 2010, 10:52AM

    thanks ... very moving

    you are very lucky to have the active support and understanding of your parents

    the ongoing problem that I have with, now thankfully generally mild, depression is the refusal of my parents to accept that such a thing even exists. It certainly doesn't make the therapeutic process any easier!

    meditation through CDs and ongoing therapy have helped me and over the last twelve months I have at the age of 46 finally become aware of what a privilege and a joy having the gift of life truly is.

Showing first 50 comments | Go to all comments | Go to latest comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and signed in.

|

Comments

Sorry, commenting is not available at this time. Please try again later.

Health: best treatments BMJ Group

Read information about the best treatments for depression in adults

Search all conditions and treatments:

This information is brought to you by the British Medical Journal in partnership with Guardian.co.uk

Eat right – check your BMI

Weight:

Height:

Gender:

Age:

salad eat right promo

Eat right

Join our healthy eating and diet club for just £2.99 a week

Free P&P at the Guardian bookshop

Browse all jobs

jobs by Indeed