(Go: >> BACK << -|- >> HOME <<)

Take your places for the new Tory parlour game: who will resign from the cabinet?

Frustrated former frontbenchers amuse themselves with bets on which ministers will quit the cabinet

Defence secretary Liam Fox
Tory MPs are wondering whether Liam Fox will be one of the first Tories to resign from the cabinet. Photograph: Christopher Thomond for the Guardian

Conservative MPs who lost out on ministerial jobs, after toiling on the frontbench during the hard years of opposition, are whiling away the hot summer months with a new game. In the bars and tearooms of Westminster they are placing bets on who will be the next minister to resign from the cabinet.

The game was disrupted when David Laws resigned as treasury chief secretary over his expenses. "I was most disappointed when David Laws resigned," one former frontbencher said. "It meant that I lost my bet that Iain Duncan Smith would be the the first minister to resign."

Duncan Smith is one of three names doing the rounds. This is how the betting goes:

Iain Duncan Smith

The former Tory leader has, according to Conservative MPs, nothing to lose. He joined the cabinet not for the perks of office but to implement his vision of how welfare should be reformed.

The new work and pensions secretary indicated to the Guardian at the end of May that he had a take it or leave it approach. He also said he had no interest in simply slashing budgets:

The purpose of my life here is to improve the quality of life of the worst off in society. If somebody tells me I have to do something different then I won't be here any longer. Tattooed across my heart is that I didn't come here in any shape or form simply as a cheeseparer. What I have come to do is look root and branch at how we deliver welfare which is aimed at groups at the bottom end of society who need help and support, either because they can't work or because they can but they are unable to get back to work, or because they are disabled.

A few weeks after the interview, George Osborne made clear in the Budget that welfare woud bear the brunt of the extra cuts – £11bn of the £32bn cuts to be precise.

Duncan Smith has made clear that he was relaxed with the Budget and is in agreement with the chancellor on the need to introduce more rigorous testing of claimants on incapacity benefit. He is also excited that he is chairing the cabinet committee that will oversee the government's approach to what used to be referred to as Broken Britain.

But MPs are wondering how happy Duncan Smith will remain when it becomes clear that the Treasury has no intention of paying for reforms suggested by his Centre for Social Justice. One idea – to move more than half a million households off welfare and into work – would eventually save £700m a year. But the Tory treasury team did not like the up-front costs.

My resignation rating: Unlikely at the moment. But message to George: don't mess with a former leader.

Liam Fox

The former Tory leadership contender has irritated Downing Street on two occasions since the election:

• Within weeks of his appointment as defence secretary, Fox offended the government in Kabul by describing Afghanistan as a "broken 13th-century country".

His remarks to the Times were meant to illustrate the new government's approach: that the priority should be stabilising Afghanistan rather than creating a perfect society. Downing Street was annoyed with Fox's lack of respect for Afghanistan.

• Last month Fox announced to the world that Air Chief Marshal Sir Jock Stirrup, the chief of the defence staff, would resign at the conclusion of the strategic defence review in the autumn.

Downing Street had agreed that Stirrup would stand down later this year. But No 10 was irritated with the way in which Fox grabbed some headlines with the announcement which was seen as discourteous to Stirrup.

This behaviour has left Tory MPs wondering what Fox is up to. The general conclusion is that he is holding aloft the Tory flame to strengthen his position, possibly putting him in the frame for the leadership, if the coalition collapses.

Fox, who put in a strong performance in the 2005 leadership contest, is the most senior cabinet figure on the Tory right after William Hague "sold the pass" on the EU. It did not escape Downing Street's attention when Fox said during the coalition negotiations in May that the Liberal Democrats should not expect to secure pet projects such as electoral reform.

My resignation rating: Unlikely. Will cause trouble but leadership ambitions mean he will hang on.

Vince Cable

The business secretary has been the subject of endless speculation that he would quit because he was so visibly uncomfortable about forming a coalition with the Tories.

But he was a key voice in persuading the Lib Dem parliamentary party to accept the coalition for two main reasons: a deal would not have worked with Labour and his party's negotiators secured a strong deal with the Tories.

Since his appointment to the cabinet, Cable has been highly supportive of the chancellor's fiscal deficit reduction plans.

My resignation rating. Unlikely on his own. Will probably only resign with other Lib Dems if coalition collapses.


Your IP address will be logged

Comments in chronological order

Post a comment
  • This symbol indicates that that person is The Guardian's staffStaff
  • This symbol indicates that that person is a contributorContributor
  • Cuse Cuse

    6 Jul 2010, 1:25PM

    I don't really care who goes first - but I hope it's Cable.

    The hypocritical, lying powder-puff has gone from being the nation's darling to being the nation's laughing stock.

    Granted - it's not as clever as his line about Brown + Mr Bean - but it's more true.

  • ralphmcgrath ralphmcgrath

    6 Jul 2010, 1:34PM

    Nick Clegg's speech to the Lib Dem spring conference 2008....

    "This talk of alliances comes up a lot. Everyone wants to be in our gang.

    So, I want to make something very clear today.

    Will I ever join a Conservative government?

    No!"

  • BtheI BtheI

    6 Jul 2010, 2:00PM

    Cable won't be first Lib Dem out. It'll either be Webb, if IDS keeps folding and nothing is done about pensions, or Huhne, if he thinks it'll make him a shoe-in for leader of the rump Lib Dems.

    As for Fox, I don't see him resigning. Being sacked when he proves himself incompetent, yes (and probably being replaced by Clegg, so he has something to do), but not resigning.

  • Bobbyb71 Bobbyb71

    6 Jul 2010, 2:27PM

    No Lib-dem will go before a Conservative. No matter how far to the right the government swings

    They're hardly a principled bunch and enjoying the perks and attention.

  • newturk newturk

    6 Jul 2010, 2:42PM

    What's the point of this "game" if they are all unlikely to resign.
    The next game for MPs and Guardian columnists to while away the hours is "will the world end this summer?"

  • JKhardie JKhardie

    6 Jul 2010, 3:17PM

    I thought it would be Cable, however upset and moody he is I can't see him have the nuts to resign.. I dropped him a note the other day saying he looked like an old firm fan who had just discovered he was in the opposition end.. he has yet to respond...

  • JKhardie JKhardie

    6 Jul 2010, 3:18PM

    Surely in the interests of balance the next minister going has to be a Tory, as the last one was a Libdum, to many Libdum defections and they will have no one left...

  • BreadHead BreadHead

    6 Jul 2010, 3:37PM

    Can't see any LibDem resigning on "principle", they'd have to have some left for that to be possible. But given their tendency to get involved in sex scandals in the style of a Major-period Tory, I can see one or two going when they're found out to have been indulging in some very unusual activities, or having lied to their electors about their "family life", or to have had snout too close to trough while bundling the cash out to a loved one.

    But on principle ? Naaah. That'd have to be a Tory. How times change.

  • charliecroker charliecroker

    6 Jul 2010, 4:07PM

    Surely the Coalition has a free run till next year anyway ? No Labour leader until September at the earliest anyway , they'll have no policies so up until then its Cameron vs Harrman, and she's just embarassing !

  • suey2y suey2y

    6 Jul 2010, 6:47PM

    First to leave?

    Osborne, when he is found in Mrs B's Blissful Emporium, sucking a dummy, wearing a nappy and being whacked with a riding crop - or is that just my image of him???

  • kevster14 kevster14

    6 Jul 2010, 8:03PM

    The Yellow Tory ministers are a pretty bland lot, seemingly lacking in principles so I doubt if they'll quit.

    Dr Cable has become very bad tempered since the election, shouting that he is being forced to do what he is doing because of what was happening in southern Europe, the markets, Gordon Brown's choice of wallpaper, etc, etc... He may stand down early as he is already in his mid 60s.

    The first to go will be the Home Secretary, a poisoned chalice and frankly Theresa May is an accident waiting to happen.

  • fortyniner fortyniner

    7 Jul 2010, 6:32AM

    It will probably be none of the above. Perhaps it will be a minister who is caught with his trousers down somewhere where he shouldn't. I'm still chuckling over John Major and Edwina Curry, even after all these years.

    Ministers come and go. We have it with all governments. And we have Cabinet reshuffles from time to time.

    Expect the unexpected.

  • EarlBH EarlBH

    7 Jul 2010, 7:10AM

    How about Nick Clegg?
    If he had ANY integrity left he would DEMAND a referrendum on PR or end this match made in Hell which is euphemistically called a 'coalition'!

  • sickboy47 sickboy47

    7 Jul 2010, 8:46AM

    Re: Cable

    a deal would not have worked with Labour and his party's negotiators secured a strong deal with the Tories.

    what's meant by a strong deal with the Tories? One where you do everything they say?

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and signed in.

|

Comments

Sorry, commenting is not available at this time. Please try again later.

Our selection of best buys

Lender Initial rate
First Direct 2.99% More
ING 2.99% More
First Direct 2.29% More
Name BT Rate BT Period
Barclaycard Platinum 0% 15 mths More
NatWest Platinum 0% 15 mths More
Royal Bank of Scotland Platinum 0% 15 mths More
Provider Typical APR
Sainsbury's Personal Loan 7.8% More
Provider AER
EGG BANKING PLC 2.80% More
ING DIRECT 2.75% More
TESCO BANK 2.75% More

Wintour and Watt blog weekly archives

Jul 2010
M T W T F S S
12 13 14 15 16 17 18
19 20 21 22 23 24 25
26 27 28 29 30 31 1

Find your MP