(Go: >> BACK << -|- >> HOME <<)

The gout myth

Gout is agony, it's on the increase - and you don't have to binge like Henry VIII to get it, writes sufferer Patrick Weir

patrick weir gout health
'My big toe felt like it was being skewered by a pitchfork' ... gout sufferer Patrick Weir at home Photograph: David Sillitoe for the Guardian

The attack came out of the blue and the pain was excruciating. Getting out of bed one morning, I placed my feet on the floor – and lurched headlong into the blanket box. My right big toe felt like it was being skewered by a pitchfork. Struggling back on to the bed, I saw that the toe and joint was swollen with a bright red sheen, and agonising to touch. Limping heavily (my wife had to steady me as I got dressed), I managed, with some effort, to manipulate my foot into a slipper.

My GP diagnosed gout. Like many people, I associated it with Henry VIII and rich living. Not quite. Gout – which comes on suddenly, over a few hours and often during the night – is determined by how well the body manages the breakdown and excretion through the kidneys of DNA protein, otherwise known as purines. If it can't control this, the purines break down to produce higher than normal levels of uric acid. These then build up and form crystals, which gather in a joint, causing inflammation and acute pain.

As many as one in 100 people will experience this at some point, rising to five in 100 for men aged 65 and over. And with people now living longer, these figures are likely to increase. It's an illness more common in men than in women, who tend to have lower levels of uric acid in their blood. It's also a condition that recurs. According to the British Medical Association, around 60% of sufferers will have a second attack within a year, more than 75% within two years, and over 80% within three years. "Incidents of gout are increasing and constitute the most acute inflammation for between 1-2% of men in the western world," says Dr Ian Rowe, a consultant rheumatologist.

Yet one of the difficult aspects of the illness for me is the assumption that it is brought on by rich living. Mention gout and people automatically assume that you gorge on rich food and down the booze in equal measure. Having limped in agony to the local shop, I mention the g-word and I am greeted by a smile and words along the lines of, "Too much of the good life, eh? You like your food and drink, eh?" And I have to put up with this whenever I explain my laboured gait.

It's true that GP's guidelines advise you to consider diet and lifestyle: moderate, or almost zero, consumption of purine-rich foods – red meat, liver, kidneys, shellfish – is recommended; and instead of red wine, stouts and spirits, I was told I should stick to a sensible intake of white wine and lager. Rowe says: "A healthy lifestyle is important. That means reducing consumption of alcohol and purine-rich foods and not going on a high-protein or crash diet."

So I couldn't help wondering if the occasional burger and bottle of red had actually been my undoing. But Richard Hull, consultant rheumatologist at Queen Alexandria hospital in Portsmouth, says not. "If my patients take their medication properly, I don't put too much emphasis on their eating habits," he says.

"Diet only affects up to 10% of purines, but of course, moderation is sensible. As for the benefits of drinking white wine, this is an old wives' tale. Consuming more than the recommended levels of alcohol does cause dehydration, which increases the likelihood of a gout attack." But the condition is also related to diabetes, kidney complaints, obesity and medications such as diuretics, or water tablets, for high blood pressure.

Even when you get treatment – usually anti-inflammatory drugs – it takes around a week to 10 days to work, and during this time the pain can be extremely disabling: lifting your foot to rest it on the sofa can cause agonising stabs. The preventative drug, allopurinol, can only be administered when the condition has calmed down, and has to be taken for the rest of your life as does the newly approved medication, febuxostat.

Since the first attack four years ago, my gout has returned annually and kept me company for a fortnight. I always keep my anti-inflammatory tablets to hand, because, despite my best efforts, I can't rule out another attack during the night.


Your IP address will be logged

Comments in chronological order

Post a comment
  • This symbol indicates that that person is The Guardian's staffStaff
  • This symbol indicates that that person is a contributorContributor

Showing first 50 comments | Go to all comments | Go to latest comment

  • hanover hanover

    6 Jul 2010, 9:40AM

    I was first diagnosed with gout when I was 25 and now I'm in my 50's. I've been on allopurinol for some years and it works though I still get the odd sudden attack - ibuprofen helps. And you're right, the pain is excruciating, though not as bad as the smart arse remarks about port and cheese.

  • eirecore eirecore

    6 Jul 2010, 9:50AM

    Look there is nothing wrong with enjoying the finer things in life and if it leads to the onset gout then so be it; I'm just amazed how all these people who get gout make out they live frugal modest existences as opposed to Rioja swilling, steak munching decadent westerners. Shocking, just shocking!

  • DoctorJimbo DoctorJimbo

    6 Jul 2010, 9:51AM

    Sorry to be a pedant, but: "DNA protein" is a contradiction. Purines are one of the building blocks of DNA, nothing to do with proteins.
    Also, Cheryl Cole's malaria is not caused by a virus, as I read three times in that article. Malaria is caused by a multicellular microorganism, Plasmodium falciparum:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plasmodium

  • Chumbles Chumbles

    6 Jul 2010, 10:11AM

    Like hanover I first had gout when I was in my mid-20s; a very unwelcome surprise and I persevered with using ibuprofen and indomethacin to reduce the swelling. I drank hardly any red wine at the time - mainly beer.

    I've since found out that yeast-based products can elevate the level of uric acid and that my daily diet of 2-3 pints was probably why I kept getting attacks - but no doctor ever told me that - just kept prescribing indomethacin; eventually a new GP asked why I wasn't on allopurinol... after many attacks, leading to early onset arthritis in my right knee, I decided that I would have to put up with taking the tablets every day. After the first month or so, 25 years later I still haven't had another attack, but I so wish I'd started sooner. Don't delay - if you are not going to spend time experimenting with and basing your diet around the condition (which might not work) then allopurinol is the only sensible solution.

    And as for pain; the level of pain in a bad attack can get to the stage when you cannot put your foot to the ground or bear even a sheet to be on top of the affected joint. As Patrick intimates, it is pain so severe that you will do almost anything to alleviate it! So, if you start getting repeated attacks of gout, then don't muck about. Get allopurinol prescribed before other damage starts to occur.

  • Merlin08 Merlin08

    6 Jul 2010, 10:21AM

    Be careful of lager on holiday. The combination of European Lagers, which tend to be stronger than UK cooking lager , and heat will triggger gout.

    Another factor is raw beef -Carpaccio/ Bresola etc -jolly nice but another gout trigger.

  • polishsupporter polishsupporter

    6 Jul 2010, 10:30AM

    I have had three extreme gout attacks in my life. It is sheer agony. I don't think I can imagine pain worse. It reminds me of treading on a plug. It is like ehaving knives stuck in your foot.

    I got gout from drinking too much. Most people do. That doesn't mean you shouldn't have sympathy.

    Some lung cancer sufferers don't smoke, but most do. Gout is generally caused by eating too much protein and drinking too much alcohol, particularly beer.

  • polishsupporter polishsupporter

    6 Jul 2010, 10:32AM

    This comment has been removed by a moderator. Replies may also be deleted.
  • Chumbles Chumbles

    6 Jul 2010, 10:36AM

    @feline1973

    Ah, my son, did you not read Patrick's excellent article? Did you not understand before skipping to the comments and adding the usual, jolly, ho ho ho, comments? It's the inability of the kidneys to process purines - the triggers are a very wide variety of different foods and circumstances. More so than you would imagine - I still avoid strawberries, because of all the fruits, in spite of the allopurinol, they will cause an attack. Which won't happen if I eat paté or drink port. And as for centuries of evidence-based observation well, beats thinking about the science, doesn't it.

    Or are you implying that as only fat rich bastards get gout, so they (we) deserve to suffer?

  • polishsupporter polishsupporter

    6 Jul 2010, 10:37AM

    hanover.

    happened to me last week and i was almost in tears.

    they come from the same school of though as

    " freddie Mercury desreved to die, because he lived a promiscuous lifestyle"

    sanctimomonoius gits

  • feline1973 feline1973

    6 Jul 2010, 10:42AM

    Well I was only asking!

    So it's the fact that these people have rubbish kidneys that gives them gout, not their diet?

    Would they have been born with rubbish kidneys? Or would they have been damaged by evil E-numbers from Big Pharma?

    @ Polishsupporter - didn't you know Freddie Mercury isn't actually dead? He's living with Kenny Everett on the dark side of the moon, the peddling antiretroviral drugs that cause AIDS and growing rich off the Big Pharma HIV conspiracy. Apparently.

  • polishsupporter polishsupporter

    6 Jul 2010, 10:44AM

    This comment has been removed by a moderator. Replies may also be deleted.
  • TheDigitalDave TheDigitalDave

    6 Jul 2010, 10:44AM

    I was first diagnosed as having gout about 10 years ago aged 47. After looking it up (as one does) on the internet I went to my doctor, told him and he said “Oh, you seem to know more about it than I do!” as he reached for a big book.
    Moving swiftly on to another surgery, after some experimentation, the daily regime of Allopurinol was settled on. It needs time for things to settle down, because it can be the changes in levels of uric acid, as much as the acid itself, which cause the crystals to occur. I was also told it could be hereditary, from the mother’s side.
    I have not been troubled with gout for years now.

  • bobinspain bobinspain

    6 Jul 2010, 10:53AM

    My first bout of gout was 15 years ago and the bad news is that the frequency of attacks increases as the years go by. An attack can last a week and I can suffer two in a month. Toe joints were the only ones affected back then, but now it can strike at knees, elbows and fingers. The worst case was an excruciatingly swollen knee joint which kept me bed-ridden for eight days. It's got so bad and so frequent, that at 61, I've stopped playing golf, because I expect to be laid low by an attack more often than not and thus walking the course is an impossibility.

    My uric acid level is 'normal', so allopurinol wasn't prescribed. Sodium Diclofenac (Voltarol) 50mg tabs 4/day eventually does the trick. Sometimes in 2 days, sometimes longer.

    I can drink and eat like a pauper, or like a Bacchanalian carnivore, it makes not a jot of difference. (I've tried the extremes and the in-betweens).

    Three months ago, having tried herbal remedies, quack-pills from the Far East and every 'grannie's recommended cure', I stumbled across apple cider vinegar, (acv). It works!

    ACV isn't a miracle cure that'll have you leaping around like a startled fawn, but in my case, although I've had just one attack of gout (when I'd have expected three in the period), the attack was very mild and reduced in duration.
    The acv should be 'with mother' a kind of cloudy, snotty slime which is the enzyme which keeps the mixture 'alive'. It's perfectly natural, with no addatives, and diluted with an equal measure of distilled water, it's quite palatable.

    Give it a try, you've nothing to lose but your gout.

  • NJS1964 NJS1964

    6 Jul 2010, 11:00AM

    I first developed gout about 20 years ago and daily Allopurionol pretty much ended the problem. However at the time of the onset I was very overweight and over the next 3 years (not because of the gout) I lost about 9 stone. I then moved and a routine test on signing up with a new GP showed there was no problem and I stopped taking the preventaitive and have had no further problems.

    I suppose my lesson is that though the author is right that it is something that can affect anyone, other factors can exist.

  • bakuninslittlehelper bakuninslittlehelper

    6 Jul 2010, 11:06AM

    I haven't drank for over thirty years and apart from attacks of self righteousness i also get the occasional attack of gout. I must admit that the pain though awful is not as terrible as the article makes it out to be, so, maybe my self diagnosis is incorrect, although I do get the red ring around the knuckle of my big toe. (Like that filthy old joke - it's not lipstick).
    What I wanted to say in a long winded way is that I have found that cherry juice seems to alleviate it, even seems to banish it. I use two kinds - Rabenhorst organic and a concentrate (it has to be diluted), whose name escapes me. In fact the concentrate says on the label that it regulates uric acid. Try it.

  • ffeingo2 ffeingo2

    6 Jul 2010, 11:11AM

    About two years ago I had my only attack of gout. My right big toe. At night, in bed. I am a 70 year old male in good health. Generally a vegetarian. Good fluid intake. (The previous day I had been taken to a restaurant and treated to a liver based soup followed by a very rich organ meat dish.) I bathed my foot alternately, and to no benefit, in hot and cold water as I desperately searched the internet. What I came up with, and what solved the problem for me, was sour cherry juice. I drank it, I did not try bathing my foot in it. Complete relief came within a day. Give it a try. I have a sour cherries weekly, just in case.

  • Frenchgeordie Frenchgeordie

    6 Jul 2010, 11:18AM

    I had several attacks in the mid-1980s. The last one was on a camping holiday in Brittany. I set off from the tent with him to the bar, about 100 metres away - and was suddenly crippled with pain. The doctor told me what is was on the spot. I had to drive back to Northern England with a gout attack as my wife refused to drive on French roads. It was so bad I had to put up in an hotel for two days in Paris. I stayed in bed and the wife and kids did Paris. The pain was excruciating. As I lay in bed I was continually reminded of Colonel Dennis Bloodknock's catchphrase - "Is there to be no relief?"

    Back home I saw the doctor who put me on Allopurinol. Since then, no problem. I eat and drink what I want and when I want it. This was 1987. If you have gout, get Allopurinol and get on with your life - including seafood, red wine and offal.

  • Frenchgeordie Frenchgeordie

    6 Jul 2010, 11:20AM

    I had several attacks in the mid-1980s. The last one was on a camping holiday in Brittany. I set off from the tent with him to the bar, about 100 metres away - and was suddenly crippled with pain. The doctor told me what is was on the spot. I had to drive back to Northern England with a gout attack as my wife refused to drive on French roads. It was so bad I had to put up in an hotel for two days in Paris. I stayed in bed and the wife and kids did Paris. The pain was excruciating. As I lay in bed I was continually reminded of Colonel Dennis Bloodknock's catchphrase - "Is there to be no relief?"

    Back home I saw the doctor who put me on Allopurinol. Since then, no problem. I eat and drink what I want and when I want it. This was 1987. If you have gout, get Allopurinol and get on with your life - including seafood, red wine and offal.

  • troyka troyka

    6 Jul 2010, 11:37AM

    My father in law suffers from gout and my wife looked it up on the internet and found varoius sites that recommended Apple Cider Vinegar.It worked!
    He still drinks more gin and red wine than he should and eats rich food..hell he´s in his mid-seventies why not..but the ACV helps when he gets an attack of gout.

  • Canadatyke Canadatyke

    6 Jul 2010, 11:43AM

    I have been susceptible to Gout for many years, but was lucky enough to be introduced to COLCHICINE which, I think, is made from Autumn Crocus. If I feel a bout coming on, I pop a couple (0.6 mg) and they seem to do the trick. My doctor says that, for some people, they can cause stomach problems.
    dave

  • stufato stufato

    6 Jul 2010, 12:12PM

    I agree with polishsupporter.
    I had gout when I was about 25 - I was working in a pub at the time and doing my best to empty the cellar. I took some horse pills for a while - don't remember what they were but they kept me awake at night with heartburn - cut down on the boozing and it went away. Since then - nothing - and I hope it stays that way because the pain was really no joke.

  • casualty casualty

    6 Jul 2010, 12:18PM

    Every person I've known who has had gout has been over weight, eats and drinks too much. If you're fit and healthly there's no chance you are going to get gout end of.

  • redsocks redsocks

    6 Jul 2010, 12:21PM

    i too have suffered from gout for many years. I recently discovered
    CHERRYGOOD in my local tesco and it is made from tart cherries. Much cheaper than anything in the health stores and it has been wonderful in relieving the pain.

  • SerendipityDom SerendipityDom

    6 Jul 2010, 12:25PM

    I would recommend anyone who has not yet done so to try a food intolerance test such as offered by various practitioners, and then adjust their food intake to match the results, thereby reducing inflammation in the body and avoiding many illnesses, including gout .... After a very long hunt, I've recently done this and am delighted with the results, as well as saddened that it took me so many years to find someone would could help (rather than offering me more chemicals, more tablets, all of which were useless and caused more harm than they did good) ....

  • djmikeyc djmikeyc

    6 Jul 2010, 12:27PM

    Every person I've known who has had gout has been over weight, eats and drinks too much. If you're fit and healthly there's no chance you are going to get gout end of.

    But, weirdly, I only know one person who's had gout and he's thin and doesn't drink.

    So it's like all illnesses, then; some people have a disposition towards it that certain lifestyle choices usually increase. You are significantly less likely to get gout if you don't drink, but some people just have rubbish kidneys. Similarly, fat people are more likely to get heart disease; but having heart disease doesn't mean you're fat or ever have been

  • Pens Pens

    6 Jul 2010, 12:31PM

    i'm sure it's different for each person, but once diagnosed i have managed to avoid having it since. i recognise the early symptoms and change my diet (no red meat, red wine to begin with) and/or take a heap of ibuprofen. it's worked so far, so hopefully it's a long term solution.

  • chingwu chingwu

    6 Jul 2010, 12:36PM

    casualty

    6 Jul 2010, 12:18PM

    Every person I've known who has had gout has been over weight, eats and drinks too much. If you're fit and healthly there's no chance you are going to get gout end of.
    ..........................................................................................................

    The only person I've ever known with gout was an ex student (I teach one of the softer styles of kung fu). He was a Tae kwon Do black belt, very fit, very active, and ate a balanced diet.

    Did you not read the article? Just fancied making snide comments did you?

  • fra19 fra19

    6 Jul 2010, 12:47PM

    just been diagnosed with gout.

    very worried about taking the drugs that are suppossed to control it as alot are famous having nasty side effects.

    Am trying hydration and diet to start with.

    any suggestions for a gout newbie would be much appreciated

  • fra19 fra19

    6 Jul 2010, 12:48PM

    just been diagnosed with gout.

    very worried about taking the drugs that are suppossed to control it as alot are famous having nasty side effects.

    Am trying hydration and diet to start with.

    any suggestions for a gout newbie would be much appreciated

  • herebutforfortune herebutforfortune

    6 Jul 2010, 12:55PM

    Intriguing to learn in comments above that apple cider vinegar and sour cherry juice have given relief to sufferers, because my neighbor, who used to get gout attacks, swears by his daily dose of fresh lemon juice - not straight of course, but a lemon's worth in food and or water on a daily basis.

  • redsocks redsocks

    6 Jul 2010, 12:58PM

    fra19...as Feline1973 so delicately put it....poppin the cherries really does seem to work. lots of articles out there about them.
    has to be tart cherries though....

  • redsocks redsocks

    6 Jul 2010, 1:06PM

    fra19...as Feline 1973 so delicately put it....poppin the cherries seems to work very well (it has for me).
    it has to be tart cherries though, lots of articles out there about it. Try cherrygood and see how it goes...be good to know if it works for someone else too.

  • k1w1london k1w1london

    6 Jul 2010, 1:17PM

    My dad has suffered for gout for ages and has tried many different things and I read an article about cherries being a good remedy that has been used for years. I found a cherry juice drink in my local waitrose and bought it for dad...he now swears by it...i think it was called Cherrygood as well

  • OhNoNotAgain OhNoNotAgain

    6 Jul 2010, 1:20PM

    I was diagnosed with gout about 15 years ago. I was living in Taiwan at the time, and because it's a punishingly hot place, seemed to be in permanent state of dehydration, and I have often wondered if this was a cause of whatever made me prone to gout attacks (could dehydration affect the kidneys? No idea.)
    Anyway, how to deal with it? Bobinspain is right in that Diclofenac will relieve things in a couple of days. And Allopurinol can keep gout at bay but isn't 100% effective (I take it but still seem to suffer one gout attack a year.)
    By far the most effective thing I have ever used for sudden attacks of gout is Colchicine, which is a natural drug derived from crocus roots. It's been around for about 200 years as a gout treatment and works like a charm. Its extracted and made up into tablets, but my GP says it's seldom proscribed today as there are concerns about toxicity. But when you have gout, these are the least of your concerns. You can buy it over the counter in Taiwan at £1 for 20 tabs and I get my in-laws to send me a hundred or so every now and then. In fact, if you wake up in the night feeling a gout attack coming on, a dose of colchcine & diclofenac together can have you mobile by lunchtime.

  • Harry34 Harry34

    6 Jul 2010, 1:29PM

    Having worked for the Pharmaceutical Company that introduced Zyloric or Zyloprim [Allopurinol in Australia where i worked] in the 1970's, we had to learn quite a bit on purine metabolism.Selling the product to G.P's was hard slog as most doctors had not seen many cases. Rheumatologists naturally saw the real gouty patients. Now retired 40 years later I never dreamed I'd get the dreaded condition!. I've been on Allopurinol for about one year after a few acute right "toe attacks"..............I'd swear there was someone pushing a fine needle into the joint.Indocid gives rapid relief within hours or enteric coated aspirin. Unfortunately this does nothing to bring down uric acid levels in one's system. AND hear is the danger, those insoluble uric acid crystals can lodge in any joint , though mainly they appear in that big toe. Our company "bible" on this topic was George Hitching"s "The hidden face of GOUT" worth reading if you have access to the Wellcome Foundation library in London.

    My general health is good and weight about right, though I am a Home Brewer, so that might be the cause!......keep a few Indocids handy........Cheers

  • muscleguy muscleguy

    6 Jul 2010, 1:46PM

    Most people (veggies and vegans excluded) eat more meat than is either good for us or necessary for healthy nutrition. Therefore if you eat 'absolutely normally' you are contributing to your gout, sorry. The same wrt alcohol, what is 'normal' is way too much for health. Alternatives can be both healthy and tasty, like the marinated tofu and veg fried rice I did last night (low salt soy sauce). Mrs Muscleguy (more carnivorous inclined than I these days) remarked about how nice it was.

    I run and as a consequence drink and want to drink much less than I used to. I now limit myself to the equivalent of two pints and that is usually only once a week (binge drinker!). It's both that I don't want to feel the drag of the morning after on the run and because I genuinely don't want it. Possibly a combination of its dehydration effect and getting my jollies from my own endorphins.

    Also if you are unlucky enough to have a genetics that makes you more sensitive to such things then you have a choice, moderate your lifestyle or suffer. Look on the bright side, your blood pressure and cholesterol levels with improve so you got your wakeup call in a less lethal form than a heart attack, stroke or embolism.

Showing first 50 comments | Go to all comments | Go to latest comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and signed in.

|

Comments

Sorry, commenting is not available at this time. Please try again later.

Health: best treatments BMJ Group

Read information about the best treatments for gout

Search all conditions and treatments:

This information is brought to you by the British Medical Journal in partnership with Guardian.co.uk

Eat right – check your BMI

Weight:

Height:

Gender:

Age:

salad eat right promo

Eat right

Join our healthy eating and diet club for just £2.99 a week

Free P&P at the Guardian bookshop

Browse all jobs

jobs by Indeed