Review
by Zac Bertschy, Oct 26th 2005Princess Tutu
DVD 2: Traum
| Synopsis: | |||
The Prince's long-lost emotions are slowly coming back to him, popping up all over the place, but rather than providing the poor lad with comfort, instead they bring about a new foe: Kraehe, the crow princess! Meanwhile the love triangle between Rue, Duck and Mytho gets cranked up to a full boil; Mytho doesn't know who he wants, although he does feel eternally connected with (and attracted to!) the mysterious and graceful Princess Tutu. When Kraehe starts interfering with Tutu's bold attempts to return the prince's shattered heart back to its former state, things start looking decidedly grim; will Tutu ever be able to mend her prince? |
|||
| Review: | |||
| After a long, seemingly endless wait, the second volume of the decidedly unique Princess Tutu has finally arrived. The four episodes on this disc largely continue the quality fairytale shoujo drama seen in the first disc; surprisingly, there's no major drop in animation or storytelling quality. Princess Tutu is considered a refreshing change of pace from the usual magical girl series, and in volume 2, it's not hard to see why. While it might be easy on first glance to dismiss the show as a ballet-themed take on the old Sailor Moon formula, nothing could be further from the truth. An elegant drama steeped in fairytale trappings, Princess Tutu is focused far more on the interpersonal relationship drama than on the show's fantastical elements. It's probably the most unique entry in the genre thus far, and volume 2 does nothing to change that. Sure, in each episode, Tutu struggles to return heart shards to her prince, but the sequence of events – even by episode nine – never quite dips into monster-of-the-week style repetition. The screenwriter is using every available second of every episode to push the story further, rather than wasting time on unimportant details (minus the comedy relief scenes, which remain mostly unfunny diversions from an otherwise fine production). Really, the show's art direction and execution are what shine the most. The animation is really quite excellent for a show based on a relatively short manga series, and the music, mostly famous tunes taken from the Nutcracker Suite, really punctuate the beauty of the visuals. The character design is fairly unique if at times a little unappealing; everyone kinda looks the same, short with big hair and huge eyes. This volume's biggest revelation is the arrival of the crow princess Kraehe, whose transformation sequence – and the veritable army of crows she brings with her – adds a suitably dark and sinister stylistic element to the series. All in all, the visual presentation of this series is second to none. The lone complaint about volume 2 concerns the tone of the series; the teenage angst in this show has been cranked up to 11, to the point where in the later episodes on this disc, the characters spend most of their time staring half-lidded at the ground, questioning themselves, their feelings, their motives, and their own self-worth. Frankly, at times it all gets a little too weighed down by the angst factor. It's a very small (albeit sometimes irritating) stain on an otherwise excellent show. The dub is something of a mixed bag leaning towards “good”. There are a lot of young girls in this series, and as with any show that features too many young characters, most of them sound really similar and many of them are clearly being performed by a grown woman struggling to sound like she's 12. Duck's voice is best when she doesn't have to match the lip flaps; in fact, any scene where you can't see the characters talk unquestionably delivers the best and most natural performance. Admittedly, Mytho's voice seems to be struggling the most, delivering his lines in a wispy sort of monotone that sounds totally unnatural and kinda forced. I understand the Japanese voice sounded like that but somehow the dub just doesn't feel very organic or realistic. Admittedly, Princess Tutu is a pretty girly show but the production values and the quality of the storytelling are very high; it's worth a look even if you're hesitant about the content. If you're a guy who doesn't want to be caught buying something where the cover looks like it belongs in the Barbie aisle of a Toys 'R Us, I highly recommend purchasing this series online and watching it privately. It's not for everyone, but most people with an appreciation for decent storytelling, great classical music and elegant artwork will find something to like about this show. |
| Grade: | Production Info: | |||
|
Overall (dub) : B
Overall (sub) : A
Story : B+
Animation : A
Art : A
Music : A
+ Great music, great animation, unique story. |
Full encyclopedia details about Release information about |
|||
|
discuss this in the forum (8 posts) |
bookmark with:
Digg
|
||||
New
York Anime Festival 2009
Coverage available now:
Yoshiyuki Tomino Q&A;
AKB 48 Live In Concert
Japanese Seiyuu and US Voice Actors Panel
Yoshiyuki Tomino Keynote and Focus Panel
Viz Media
Manga Entertainment
Bandai Entertainment
Del Rey
Aniplex
Vertical Industry Panel
Tokyopop Industry Panel
Funimation Industry Panel
Opening Ceremonies
2009-09-25
RIGHT
TURN ONLY!! - Detroit Metal Alchemist
Who would win in a fight, Ed from Fullmetal Alchemist or Negi from Negima!? Either way, Krauser from Detroit Metal City probably wants in on the action! Watch them battle for manga dominance in this week's column! 2009-09-29
Who would win in a fight, Ed from Fullmetal Alchemist or Negi from Negima!? Either way, Krauser from Detroit Metal City probably wants in on the action! Watch them battle for manga dominance in this week's column! 2009-09-29
Kannagi
Fan-Art Contest Winners
Contest
2009-09-27
ANN Needs New Hardware
Help ANN set-up another goddess
2009-09-25
Help ANN set-
∨ advertisement ∨
Shugo Chara! works on different levels, and for those who can enjoy both the kiddie side and the edgy grown-
Spit and polish notwithstanding, you're better off sticking to the television series.
Nearly smothered under outlandishly risqué costuming and retread story ideas is some surprisingly entertaining content which mixes humor with a semblance of true sentiment and actual plot. Although still far from great, the series is definitely better in its second half than it looked like at first.
Ah, Darkside Blues…that 80 minute refugee from the good old days of violent, post-
Big Windup! Part 2 DVD
The problems with this second half are not enough to derail the show, but the experience is way less satisfying than it should be. Such is the power of its characters that I still can't help but love the whole package.
The problems with this second half are not enough to derail the show, but the experience is way less satisfying than it should be. Such is the power of its characters that I still can't help but love the whole package.
.hack//G.U. Trilogy Sub.DVD
A big sloppy mess with some snazzy imagery, a few cutting shards of romance, and some excellent acting by a top-flight cast.
Gankutsuou: The Count of Monte Cristo GN 3
The manga version puts the focus back on the most interesting character: the Count himself. As a result, the plot reaches full steam in a very powerful way—but sadly gets derailed in the later chapters.
The manga version puts the focus back on the most interesting character: the Count himself. As a result, the plot reaches full steam in a very powerful way—but sadly gets derailed in the later chapters.
Cencoroll
It's a film that defies any and all expectations of both medium and genre, that makes us marvel and has really little time to do much else.
It's a film that defies any and all expectations of both medium and genre, that makes us marvel and has really little time to do much else.
Blade of the Immortal GN 20-21
Is everything one could ask for in a climax: violent, smart and brimming with gory schadenfruede.
One of the odder takes on vampire lore continues in a manga series that's now clearly leaning towards being a vampire-